Pretoria High Court sets aside public protector's Vrede dairy project report

The Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has set aside Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane's report into the Estina dairy farm project in Vrede on Monday.

The court found that Mkhwebane's report was invalid and unconstitutional.

The application was brought by the Democratic Alliance (DA) and the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution (Casac).

Read: 'Parliament should have proper inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office'

The report itself has been deemed invalid and judgment on costs has been reserved.

To discuss the judgment, Ray White on the Xolani Gwala Show speaks to Casac executive secretary Lawson Naidoo.

When the public protector released her report last year, it was quite clear that the report was a whitewash as implicated politicians were never interviewed. The report hadn't adequately investigated the complaint that had been laid against her by a member of the provincial legislature in the Free State with her office.

Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Cosac

He says it appeared to them that Mkhwebane had conducted a very narrow investigation that resulted in remedial action that was just a slap on the wrist for individuals that were implicated.

The public protector made significant amendments to a provisional report that was prepared by her predecessor. She gave no reason why she changed some of the remedial action that was in that report. That called into question her impartiality in investigating this matter, and that was the basis we took the case to the courts, and the court agreed with us.

Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Cosac

Listen below to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'We cannot be living in a country of corruption and no one is prosecuted'

'We cannot be living in a country of corruption and no one is prosecuted'

Mmusi Maimane has handed over evidence to the NPA which he claims links Ace Magashule to corruption.

Mkhwebane holds onto her job as Parly puts breaks on inquiry plans

Mkhwebane holds onto her job as Parly puts breaks on inquiry plans

The DA and the African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP) wanted an expedited inquiry into Mkhwebane's fitness to hold office.

New NDPP described as an 'excellent' pick by the president

New NDPP described as an 'excellent' pick by the president

Eyewitness News reporter Clement Manyathela says most political parties have welcomed the appointment.

New NDPP has work cut out for her after NPA provisionally withdraws Estina case

New NDPP has work cut out for her after NPA provisionally withdraws Estina case

The NPA withdrew the case when all of the accused appeared in the Bloemfontein Magistrates Court on Tuesday morning.

'NPA was right to provisionally withdraw charges in Estina Farm saga' - OUTA

'NPA was right to provisionally withdraw charges in Estina Farm saga' - OUTA

Chief Executive Officer at OUTA,Wayne Duvenage says the NPA may need to regroup and get its facts together.

[LISTEN] Home Affairs never verified Ajay Gupta’s family investment claims

[LISTEN] Home Affairs never verified Ajay Gupta’s family investment claims

The Home Affairs Portfolio Committee has heard how the department did not probe any further about the family's investments.

Two high profile state capture cases in the hands of the NPA could be in trouble

Two high profile state capture cases in the hands of the NPA could be in trouble

According to City Press investigative journalist, the two cases are the Estina dairy farm and allegations made by Mcebisi Jonas.

Public Protector: I demand an apology for “unseemly public attacks”

Public Protector: I demand an apology for “unseemly public attacks”

Busisiwe Mkhwebane has told Parliament's Justice Committee to apologise to her for attacks and threats to remove her from office.

FS High Court rules in favour of the Guptas in the Estina Dairy Farm case

FS High Court rules in favour of the Guptas in the Estina Dairy Farm case

The court has found that there is no reasonable grounds for believing that the State could secure successful prosecution.

Popular articles
Can’t find your phone? Drop everything – thieves can get into your banking app!

Can’t find your phone? Drop everything – thieves can get into your banking app!

Did someone steal your phone? Contact your bank without hesitation warns consumer journalist Wendy Knowler.

'Unions are making a mistake. SAA is dying. It’s not Eskom – we don’t need it'

'Unions are making a mistake. SAA is dying. It’s not Eskom – we don’t need it'

SAA is on its knees, cap in hand, asking taxpayers for R2 billion this month. Unions must be careful, warns Guy Leitch (SA Flyer).

[WATCH] Jozi motorist avoids hailstorm with inventive way to cover car

[WATCH] Jozi motorist avoids hailstorm with inventive way to cover car

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

White pupils at posh Kingswood College refer to black scholars as 'snoobab'

White pupils at posh Kingswood College refer to black scholars as 'snoobab'

"This problem is bigger than just a Kingswood problem. The relevant processes will unfold," says College Head Colleen Vassiliou.

[WATCH] Pre-school class erupts as boy returns from RWC, goes viral

[WATCH] Pre-school class erupts as boy returns from RWC, goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

We’ll shut you down! – unions to SAA ('overstaffed by any measure globally’)

We’ll shut you down! – unions to SAA ('overstaffed by any measure globally’)

The money-pit airline is fighting for its life. Bruce Whitfield interviews Theto Mahlakoana, a senior political reporter at EWN.

[WATCH] Gay teen fights back against school bully as teachers do nothing

[WATCH] Gay teen fights back against school bully as teachers do nothing

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

'I don’t need millions. All I want on my tombstone is... Best Dad Ever'

'I don’t need millions. All I want on my tombstone is... Best Dad Ever'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Pilgrim about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).