Will Mkhwebane's report stop Ramaphosa from appointing Gordhan?

Former public enterprises minister Pravin Gordhan in an affidavit says the timing of Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane's report that found against him was part of an effort to empower proponents of state capture and was politically motivated.

Mkhwebane last Friday found Gordhan guilty of improper conduct regarding an early retirement payout of former South African Revenue Service deputy commissioner Ivan Pillay.

Read: Gordhan questions timing of Mkhwebane's report in affidavit

The former minister applied on Tuesday to have Mkhwebane' s report reviewed and set aside.

Melanie Rice, in for CapeTalk's Refilwe Moloto, chats to constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos about the battle between Gordhan and Mkhwebane.

At the heart of this is the logic that says Gordhan got legal advice from, I think, five different people and they all said what he was doing was legal, and she found that it was not legal.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

Of course, Judge Nugent in his report found that it was legal; so the question is then if you disagree with the legal advice that you received, does that render you unfit to hold public office? Regardless of the technicalities, my answer would be 'no' because you have not done anything in bad faith.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

De Vos says he does not know whether the action by Gordhan could lead to Mkhwebane losing her job as there are already other court findings that cited that the Public Protector misled the court.

Also read: Gordhan's lawyer: challenge to Mkhwebane submitted to courts on Tuesday.

There is already sufficient evidence from three different court judgments in which the court not only reviewed and set aside her reports but also said that she misled the courts and that there are suggestions of an ulterior purpose - and that she has no clue what her powers are and how to exercise them.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

He adds that in terms of the law, President Cyril Ramaphosa has the power to do whatever he wants when it comes to Cabinet appointments.

He can appoint someone for a day or a week and then remove them, and that is his prerogative.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

Listen below to the full interview:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Will Mkhwebane's report stop Ramaphosa from appointing Gordhan?


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Until found otherwise, Ramaphosa isn't barred from appointing Gordhan'

'Until found otherwise, Ramaphosa isn't barred from appointing Gordhan'

Political analyst Lesiba Teffo says Gordhan is one of the president's trusted candidates and should be appointed to Cabinet.

'If Gordhan feels that Mkhwebane has erred, let him take the case on review'

'If Gordhan feels that Mkhwebane has erred, let him take the case on review'

ANC member Phapano Phasha discusses her letter to the party's integrity commission regarding the Public Protector's report.

Gordhan questions timing of Mkhwebane's report in affidavit

Gordhan questions timing of Mkhwebane's report in affidavit

EWN senior reporter Barry Bateman says the former public enterprises minister argues that the matter is politically motivated.

Gordhan's lawyer: challenge to Mkhwebane submitted to courts on Tuesday.

Gordhan's lawyer: challenge to Mkhwebane submitted to courts on Tuesday.

Tebogo Malatji says the Public Protector's decision and remedial actions don't make sense and will be challenged in court.

Mkhwebane has outstayed her welcome as Public Protector says Casac

Mkhwebane has outstayed her welcome as Public Protector says Casac

Casac says one of the tests of the new Parliament will be whether it takes seriously concerns over Mkwebhane's fitness for office.

'Mkhwebane got it wrong in fact and in law,' says Gordhan's lawyer

'Mkhwebane got it wrong in fact and in law,' says Gordhan's lawyer

Former Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan's lawyer Tebogo Malatji responds to Public Protector Mkhwebane's report.

Judge Kriegler: Public Protector has made a number of strategic mistakes

Judge Kriegler: Public Protector has made a number of strategic mistakes

The chair of Freedom Under Law comments on Busisiwe Mkhwebane's report finding that Pravin Gordhan acted improperly at Sars.

'President in tricky position to appoint people not accused of wrongdoing'

'President in tricky position to appoint people not accused of wrongdoing'

Political analyst Professor Tinyiko Maluleke on President Cyril Ramaphosa's decision to announce his Cabinet later this week.

New Cabinet must advance the interest of our people  - Cosatu general secretary

New Cabinet must advance the interest of our people - Cosatu general secretary

Bheki Ntshalintshali discusses the task ahead for President Ramaphosa and the high court ruling against the Public Protector.

Popular articles
Budget 2020 made simple: how does it impact my personal finances?

Budget 2020 made simple: how does it impact my personal finances?

Wealth builder Warren Ingram on how the new budget affects you.

Spur to open 11 more outlets in South Africa

Spur to open 11 more outlets in South Africa

Spur releases results saying it plans to open 11 outlets in SA and 17 internationally in the second half of the year.

Massmart explains store closures and retrenchments in the face of a R1.3bn loss

Massmart explains store closures and retrenchments in the face of a R1.3bn loss

Massmart has withheld their dividend as it swings to a R1.3bn loss

'Blame Madiba  and Mbeki for Eskom' - unions vow to fight Budget 2020 wage cuts

'Blame Madiba and Mbeki for Eskom' - unions vow to fight Budget 2020 wage cuts

''Government is speaking with forked tongue and Budget 2020 came as a shock''. Unions want to fight planned wage cuts.

 #Budget2020: There is a huge sense of relief among retailers - Edcon

#Budget2020: There is a huge sense of relief among retailers - Edcon

On Wednesday Finance Minister Tito Mboweni said there would be no new income tax hikes this year.

Cape Winelands farm workers protest following eviction of six family members

Cape Winelands farm workers protest following eviction of six family members

Women on Farms co-director Carmen Louw says they hope the Extension of Security of Tenure Act will be amended.

Levels of child hunger have decreased in SA but concerns remain around stunting

Levels of child hunger have decreased in SA but concerns remain around stunting

Joanne Joseph speaks to University of Cape Town Children’s Institute's communications and education specialist Lori Lake.

Public Protector makes damning findings against Lesedi Municipality

Public Protector makes damning findings against Lesedi Municipality

Eyewitness News reporter Edwin Ntshidi gives a summary of the findings made by Mkhwebane.

Workplace toxicity: In a new exponential world, command and control doesn't work

Workplace toxicity: In a new exponential world, command and control doesn't work

Azania Mosaka speaks to Cycan CEO Bryan Hattingh about the difference between a tough leader and a toxic leader.

What Prince? 'He made it clear that he just wants to be called Harry'

What Prince? 'He made it clear that he just wants to be called Harry'

EWN UK correspondent Gavin Grey says the prince completed his final round of royal duties on Wednesday in Scotland.