EFF-Manuel ruling: 'It's an important judgment in this post-truth era'

The Johannesburg High Court on Thursday ruled that comments made by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) about former finance Trevor Manuel were "defamatory and false".

Manuel took legal action against the party for suggesting that South African Revenue Services (Sars) commissioner Edward Kieswetter’s appointment was based on nepotism.

Read: EFF to appeal Manuel defamation ruling

The court ordered the party to apologise to Manuel within 24 hours and pay R500,000 in damages.

The EFF has said that it will appeal this judgment and Manuel has told EWN that he will donate the money he won from the suit to pensioners who lost their money in the VBS Mutual Bank collapse.

To dissect the judgment, Eusebius McKaiser speaks to social media law specialist Emma Sadleir.

Sadleir says it has been a principle in South African defamation law that even though we have robust protection of freedom of expression, that protection has never extended to falsehoods.

I think this is an important judgment of this post-truth era that we all live in, where there is so much fake news and people thinking that they can just post what they like on social networks. The law has never said that is ok. If you want to post what you like, then you must know what you are saying is both true and for the benefit of the public.

Emma Sadleir, Social media law specialist

She says the court found that the was no truth to the EFF's claims and if there was truth, the party would be entitled to post these statements.

Also read: Trevor Manuel threatens legal action against EFF for SARS commissioner claims

Strong opinions are protected in South African law, but that doesn't extend to where there is no truth.

Emma Sadleir, Social media law specialist

Sadlier adds that the reach of social media these days is far greater than the reach of a newspaper.

It is straightforward to sue someone for defamation. You only have to show three things, firstly that the defamatory act refers to you. Secondly, you have to show that it was published and the third thing is that the defamatory action affects your reputation.

Emma Sadleir, Social media law specialist

She says the court found that there was no truth substantial in the EFF's claims thus ruling in Manuel's favour.

Listen below to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Without functioning committees, Parliament will not function'

'Without functioning committees, Parliament will not function'

Eusebius McKaiser and different pundits dissect the purpose of Scopa in South Africa's sixth administration.

Salga opposes Treasury's stance on consultants

Salga opposes Treasury's stance on consultants

South African Local Government Association chairperson Thembi Nkadimeng says the organisation was not consulted.

Tips on when to self-medicate

Tips on when to self-medicate

Clinical psychologist Cassandra Govender says if you are going to self-medicate with psychiatric meds, consult a psychiatrist.

EFF to appeal Manuel defamation ruling

EFF to appeal Manuel defamation ruling

Economic Freedom Fighters have instructed lawyers to file papers by Friday.

EFF says they tried every channel to have nepotism claims against Manuel probed

EFF says they tried every channel to have nepotism claims against Manuel probed

The party appeared in court after the former finance minister took legal action, accusing them of defamation.

Trevor Manuel threatens legal action against EFF for SARS commissioner claims

Trevor Manuel threatens legal action against EFF for SARS commissioner claims

The EFF has objected to Sars boss Edward Kieswetter's appointment, claiming the new commissioner is related to Trevor Manuel.

Popular articles
[WATCH] SA youth choir shines on America's Got Talent with 'My African Dream'

[WATCH] SA youth choir shines on America's Got Talent with 'My African Dream'

The Ndlovu Youth Choir's beautiful performance got 4 yesses from the judges, including Simon Cowell!

[WATCH] Dad promises son a PlayStation 5 if he hits crossbar, and he does

[WATCH] Dad promises son a PlayStation 5 if he hits crossbar, and he does

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

TymeBank CEO Sandile Shabalala quits

TymeBank CEO Sandile Shabalala quits

Shabalala says he wants to spend more time with his family. Bruce Whitfield interviews portfolio manager Kokkie Kooyman (Denker).

Average salary in SA is R6400 per month, but 70% of workers earn less

Average salary in SA is R6400 per month, but 70% of workers earn less

About 29% of workers earn less than the R3500 national minimum wage, says Anish Shivdasani, CEO at Giraffe.

'Elephant in the room is labour law and the labour movement'

'Elephant in the room is labour law and the labour movement'

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews economists Andrew Levy (Andrew Levy Employment) and Dr Azar Jammine (Econometrix).

Investec gives staff unlimited leave days and freedom to wear what they want

Investec gives staff unlimited leave days and freedom to wear what they want

The bank rewards innovation with substantial bonuses and pays according to output not hours at work, says Lesley-Anne Gatter.

JSE Limited lost 10% of its value on Monday

JSE Limited lost 10% of its value on Monday

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nicky Newton-King, CEO at the JSE Limited.

We've technologist on record saying she'll not treat patients - Discovery Health

We've technologist on record saying she'll not treat patients - Discovery Health

CEO Dr Broomberg has rubbished reports that a KwaZulu-Natal patient died after the company stopped payments.

'We are not investigating the so-called R400m,' says Public Protector's office

'We are not investigating the so-called R400m,' says Public Protector's office

Spokesperson Oupa Segwale discusses the scope of Busisiwe Mkhwebane's investigation of Cyril Ramaphosa's ANC campaign funding.