Analysts debate Reserve Bank mandate

The African National Congress (ANC) secretary-general Ace Magashule's announcement that the national executive committee (NEC) lekgotla decided that the mandate of the Reserve Bank is expanded to include growth and employment, sparked a debate on whether the Reserve Bank should have a dual mandate.

Read: ANC Sarb spat takes to Twitter: 'Is there policy uncertainty?' tweets Jacob Zuma

Several party heavyweights disputed Magashule's stance and reassured investors that Reserve Bank's mandate would not be expanded.

On Thursday President Cyril Ramaphosa released a statement reaffirming the mandate of the reserve bank, describing the current spat as "not helpful".

Also read: ANC contradicts the ANC on economy while South Africans get poorer and poorer

To discuss the mandate of the Reserve Bank, Bongani Bingwa speaks to Centre for Economic Development and Transformation founding director Duma Gqubule and Wits School of Business head professor Jannie Rossouw.

I think we should change the mandate and the reason for that is that in 1997 former England Reserve Bank governor Mervyn King said: 'Inflation matters are people who only look at inflation and not other issues like employment and the economy.' Two decades later most central banks in the world do not just look at inflation. If you look at the past few months, global growth is slowing down and every central bank in the world is looking to cut interest rates and ours is not.

Duma Gqubule, Founding director - Centre for Economic Development and Transformation

He says India on Thursday cut its interest rates for the third time this year because the country's growth rate fell to 5.4% and that is not enough to create growth that will create jobs for 11 million people.

Rossouw says the Reserve Bank should aim at containing inflation because inflation makes everyone in the country poorer.

You cannot compare South Africa to other countries. Inflation is not a policy instrument. The Reserve Bank is ideally suited to contain inflation. When South African tried what Magashule is talking about, things went horribly wrong.

Professor Jannie Rossouw, Head - Wits School of Business

If the bank wasn't independent, it would have been a victim of state capture.

Professor Jannie Rossouw, Head - Wits School of Business

Listen below to the two pundits discuss their thoughts on what should happen to the Reserve Bank:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
ANC Sarb spat takes to Twitter: 'Is there policy uncertainty?' tweets Jacob Zuma

ANC Sarb spat takes to Twitter: 'Is there policy uncertainty?' tweets Jacob Zuma

Shortly after President Ramaphosa released a statement reaffirming the mandate of the reserve bank, others contradicted him.

ANC contradicts the ANC on economy while South Africans get poorer and poorer

ANC contradicts the ANC on economy while South Africans get poorer and poorer

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews Clement Manyathela (EWN) and Kevin Lings, Chief Economist at Stanlib Asset Management.

'Ramaphosa needs to stand up and be counted, help the ANC make bold decisions'

'Ramaphosa needs to stand up and be counted, help the ANC make bold decisions'

Former Gauteng premier Mbhazima Shilowa says the ANC leadership is too busy with public spats instead of focusing on the country.

Ace Magashule's ANC wants to 'explore' the printing of money

Ace Magashule's ANC wants to 'explore' the printing of money

Bruce Whitfield interviews Sarb Governor Lesetja Kganyago, Peter Attard Montalto (Intellidex) and Mpumelelo Mkhabela (Unisa).

'Magashule's stance on the Reserve Bank bluntly undermines Ramaphosa's new dawn'

'Magashule's stance on the Reserve Bank bluntly undermines Ramaphosa's new dawn'

Pan African Investment and Research Services CEO Iraj Abedian says South Africa doesn't need two centres of power.

'ANCYL national exec committee no longer has constitutional mandate to lead'

'ANCYL national exec committee no longer has constitutional mandate to lead'

Youth league member Zuko Godlimpi says the structure has been moribund for the past seven years, urges mother body to intervene.

Popular articles
 'When languages are being let go of in favour of English, we lose identity'

'When languages are being let go of in favour of English, we lose identity'

Joanne Joseph spoke to Play Africa founder and CEO Gretchen Wilson-Prangley on International Language Day.

'There is a stated commitment to deal with TRC cases but it's taking too long'

'There is a stated commitment to deal with TRC cases but it's taking too long'

Former commissioner Yasmin Sooka says it has been a 16-year battle trying to get the NPA to prosecute TRC-related cases.

We have invested heavily in driver and passenger safety - Uber

We have invested heavily in driver and passenger safety - Uber

Uber Sub-Saharan Africa general manager Alon Lit says their prices have not changed drastically since 2013.

 Tegeta's R3.7-billion coal supply contract with Eskom set aside

Tegeta's R3.7-billion coal supply contract with Eskom set aside

SIU spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago says the court has given the unit the green light to institute legal action against the company.

Protesters torch two suspected drug dens in Parow over Tazne van Wyk killing

Protesters torch two suspected drug dens in Parow over Tazne van Wyk killing

Eyewitness News reporter Lizelle Persens gives an update from the protest in Parow.

[LISTEN]  Craig Urbani talks Rocky Horror and playing Frank-N-Furter

[LISTEN] Craig Urbani talks Rocky Horror and playing Frank-N-Furter

The actor and singer joined Azania Mosaka in studio for this week's Friday Profile.

[WATCH] Glimpse of Simon & Garfunkel Songbook performance

[WATCH] Glimpse of Simon & Garfunkel Songbook performance

Make sure you don't miss the Simon & Garfunkel Songbook national tour taking place in Johannesburg, Cape Town and Sasolburg.

Azania, Bongani queue for new model flip phone

Azania, Bongani queue for new model flip phone

PARTNER CONTENT: Samsung's new Galaxy Z Flip has South Africa, and our presenters, abuzz - and it launched in SA today!

Jacob Zuma is coming back to Mzansi, supporters told to gather at OR Tambo

Jacob Zuma is coming back to Mzansi, supporters told to gather at OR Tambo

Committee member of the Gauteng RET Zuma supporters Carl Niehaus says supporters must arrive before 10am.

Dudu Myeni 'unwilling to spend her money on delinquency case, feels targeted'

Dudu Myeni 'unwilling to spend her money on delinquency case, feels targeted'

Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse chief legal officer Advocate Stefanie Fick shares the latest.