Lawyers want 'perverse' race and gender quotas to be declared unconstitutional

A quota row has hit the Cape Town legal fraternity after a black female advocate was denied a position on the Western Cape's Legal Practice Council (LPC) in favour of a coloured male advocate.

That's despite her receiving the greatest number of votes in the LPC elections.

The seat that she, on a democratic basis, would have acquired with 138 votes has been allocated to someone else, a coloured male who received only 30 votes.

Andrew Breitenbach, Chairperson - Cape Bar

Andrew Breitenbach, chairperson of the Cape Bar explains how the result came about.

The minister of justice and correctional services and the national LPC between them made regulations and rules prescribing the racial and gender composition of the provincial LPC.

Andrew Breitenbach, Chairperson - Cape Bar

The quotas for the Western Cape dictate that 50% of the advocate members of the provincial LPC must be male, 50% must be white, 50% must be black and 50% female.

Basically, if Advocate Mayosi had been declared elected there would be too many women on the council.

Andrew Breitenbach, Chairperson - Cape Bar

A high court application has been launched by the Cape Bar seeking to have the quotas declared discriminatory and unconstitutional.

Breitenbach says the Cape Bar supports "rational" affirmative action measures, but not where they produce "perverse" results.

The aim of these, essentially affirmative action measures, is to affirm and enhance the position of black, female people... white men in our profession continue to dominate in leadership positions.

Andrew Breitenbach, Chairperson - Cape Bar

The problem here is, the way these provisions have been framed is they impose a cap on the numbers of black and female members, which the unintended consequence that you have job reservation for white and male members - that can't be reconciled with transformation.

Andrew Breitenbach, Chairperson - Cape Bar

Listen to the full interview below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Lawyers want 'perverse' race and gender quotas to be declared unconstitutional


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
England legend Jeremy Guscott blasted for calls to change rugby substitution law

England legend Jeremy Guscott blasted for calls to change rugby substitution law

Stormers coach John Dobson has slammed Jeremy Guscott's proposal as a preposterous idea which could never work for the sport.

Netflix and other streaming operators to crack down on password-sharing

Netflix and other streaming operators to crack down on password-sharing

Regular password resets, two-step authentification, accounts geo-fencing and even possible fingerprint IDs could be on the cards.

Skepticism over new 'fake rhino horn' and its intended effects

Skepticism over new 'fake rhino horn' and its intended effects

A team of scientists have created a product similar to rhino horn in an effort to confuse the trade.

About 400 jobs to be lost when ArcelorMittal closes Saldanha steel plant - mayor

About 400 jobs to be lost when ArcelorMittal closes Saldanha steel plant - mayor

Marius Koen says the municipality had even offered steelmaker 20% rebate on its water bill in a bid to keep it up and running.

Mkhwebane, Sars boss clash over Zuma tax records - who has greater legal muscle?

Mkhwebane, Sars boss clash over Zuma tax records - who has greater legal muscle?

The legal battle between Sars and Mkhwebane will make clear the powers of the public protector's office when it comes to tax info.

Winde explains why Western Cape wants to urgently import gas

Winde explains why Western Cape wants to urgently import gas

Premier Alan Winde explains why his provincial government is lobbying for a licence to import liquefied natural gas (LNG).

Popular articles
'Drought is so bad that farmers are taking own lives'

'Drought is so bad that farmers are taking own lives'

South African Water Warriors co-convenor Isabel Coetzee says the country cannot sit back and lose farmers because of the crises.

[WATCH] Gay teen fights back against school bully as teachers do nothing

[WATCH] Gay teen fights back against school bully as teachers do nothing

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Meet the women who ensured that the Boks were in top form to bring home the cup

Meet the women who ensured that the Boks were in top form to bring home the cup

The all-female team of sports physiotherapists played a key role in the management team backing the Boks during the World Cup.

Caller defends Sho Madjozi's two-channels statement

Caller defends Sho Madjozi's two-channels statement

Eusebius McKaiser and callers debate issues from the Sho Madjozi to the Springboks.

BEE has not worked, says Capitec CEO

BEE has not worked, says Capitec CEO

Capitec CEO Gerrie Fourie explains the challenges the bank, named Top 100 Company of the Year, faces.

'Aarto Act could be used by Sanral to enforce e-toll compliance'

'Aarto Act could be used by Sanral to enforce e-toll compliance'

Justice Project SA chair Howard Dembovsky says the act presumes a motorist to be guilty until he or she proves they are innocent.

[VIDEO] Family saved from being hit by speeding SUV goes viral

[VIDEO] Family saved from being hit by speeding SUV goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[WATCH] Khanyi Mbau's message for iPhone charger cable thieves goes viral

[WATCH] Khanyi Mbau's message for iPhone charger cable thieves goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Bryan Habana opens up about money, and now having to buy his own clothes

Bryan Habana opens up about money, and now having to buy his own clothes

Bruce Whitfield interviews the legendary Springbok about his attitude toward money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.)