Court rules in favour of Gordhan, Mkhwebane slapped with cost order

The Pretoria High Court on Monday ruled in favour in favour of Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan.

The court has suspended the enforcement of the remedial action in relation to Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane's South African Revenue Service (Sars) rogue-unit investigation, pending a review.

RELATED: Mkhwebane to oppose Gordhan’s court bid to set aside her report on rogue unit

Mkhwebane found that Gordhan violated the Constitution by establishing the investigative unit saying it was illegal.

Then Gordhan applied for an urgent interdict after Mkhwebane instructed President Cyril Ramaphosa to initiate disciplinary hearings against the minister within 30 days of that report.

RELATED: Gordhan has no option but to interdict Mkhwebane's report - lawyer

Mkhwebane also gave National Assembly Speaker Thandi Modise 14 days to refer Gordhan to the ethics committee for violating executives members ethics code.

To discuss the court judgment, Clement Manyathela on the Xolani Gwala Show chats to EWN reporter Barry Bateman.

Judge Sulet Potterill essentially found that all the requirements that needed to be met in order to grant an interim order have been met by Gordhan. This relates to him showing that he has a prima facie right in terms of the various aspects of Mkhwebane's report which he is challenging.

Barry Bateman, Reporter - EWN

Bateman says Judge Potterill added that the remedial action that was ordered which include the disciplinary hearing, that could result in Gordhan being fired as a minister, could cause reputable harm to the minister.

However, there is no harm that could be caused to Mkhwebane by having the remedial action delayed until the matter is finally adjudicated, he notes.

Not only has the court ruled in favour of Gordhan, but it has also slapped Mkhwebane and the Economic Freedom Fighters with a cost order.

Barry Bateman, Reporter - EWN

Listen below to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Mathematics syllabus is enormous to be covered within a year,' says expert

'Mathematics syllabus is enormous to be covered within a year,' says expert

Wits University mathematics lecturer Dr Jacques du Plessis says teachers are racing against time in the classroom.

Former Reserve Bank deputy governor Daniel Mminele appointed Absa CEO

Former Reserve Bank deputy governor Daniel Mminele appointed Absa CEO

Absa head of corporate communications Songezo Zibi says Mminele has pedigree both in terms of policy and commercial banking.

 'Mkhwebane should quit as Public Protector after ConCourt judgment'

'Mkhwebane should quit as Public Protector after ConCourt judgment'

Accountability Now director advocate Paul Hoffman says a lawyer has no business lying and misleading courts.

[LISTEN] ConCourt judgment makes Mkhwebane's position a lot weaker - Friedman

[LISTEN] ConCourt judgment makes Mkhwebane's position a lot weaker - Friedman

Professor Steven Friedman gives his take on Monday's ruling and what this means politically.

'Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane made lots of mistakes and simply lied'

'Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane made lots of mistakes and simply lied'

Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane lied and acted in bad faith, the ConCourt ruled. Bruce Whitfield interviews Dr Cathy Powell.

Mkhwebane: Ramaphosa deliberately misled Parliament on Bosasa donation

Mkhwebane: Ramaphosa deliberately misled Parliament on Bosasa donation

Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane has found that President Cyril Ramaphosa deliberately misled Parliament in relation to the R500,000 Bosasa donation.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] Centre for the Less Good Idea keeps the arts alive during lockdown

[LISTEN] Centre for the Less Good Idea keeps the arts alive during lockdown

The centre is an interdisciplinary incubator space for the arts based in Maboneng, Johannesburg.

[WATCH] LeadSA applauds frontline heroes running with the baton

[WATCH] LeadSA applauds frontline heroes running with the baton

LeadSA applauds everyday heroes standing in the frontlines making a difference in communities.

Informal traders confused about lockdown regulations

Informal traders confused about lockdown regulations

City of Cape Town says the process of issuing permits to informal food traders only applies to those selling uncooked foods.

[LOCKDOWN] Alcohol and cigarette ban costing SA billions - Justice Project SA

[LOCKDOWN] Alcohol and cigarette ban costing SA billions - Justice Project SA

Chairperson Howard Dembovsky says for both we are losing about R135-million per day in levies and revenues.

Protective gear: 'There's trust breakdown between government and public sector'

Protective gear: 'There's trust breakdown between government and public sector'

Nehawu has filed urgent court papers against the Department of Health for failure to protect workers during COVID-19 outbreak.

Scopa chairperson warns government against corruption during COVID-19

Scopa chairperson warns government against corruption during COVID-19

Mkhuleko Hlengwa has expressed his concerns about the potential corrupt activities that may occur amidst the coronavirus.

East London prison officials awaiting COVID-19 results in self-isolation

East London prison officials awaiting COVID-19 results in self-isolation

Correctional Services spokesperson Singabakho Nxumalo says a female official tested positive after attending a funeral.

What needs to be achieved for the national lockdown to be lifted?

What needs to be achieved for the national lockdown to be lifted?

NICD's professor Cheryl Cohen says there will be a need for some kind of social distancing measures to be put in place.

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson battles COVID-19 in intensive care unit

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson battles COVID-19 in intensive care unit

Johnson tested positive for coronavirus 11 days ago.

[WATCH] Brothers creating a movie drive in experience in their garage goes viral

[WATCH] Brothers creating a movie drive in experience in their garage goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.