'EFF attack on good faith of court is extremely dangerous and deplorable'

Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane has expressed disappointment at Monday’s ruling by Judge Sulet Potterill of the North Gauteng High Court in the case brought by Minister of Public Enterprises, Mr. Pravin Gordhan, against her office.

Monday's judgment was handed down in the Gauteng High Court which effectively suspended the enforcement of the remedial action in the report Public Protector's report into the unit.

Kieno Kammies speaks to former Constitutional Court Justice, Judge Johan Kriegler of Freedom Under Law about the Public Protector's intention to appeal the interdict granted to Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan.

The EFF is behaving in a manner which is devaluing, delegitimising and breaking down the authority of the courts also now. That is an extremely dangerous and deplorable line to be adopting.

Judge Johann Kriegler, Chairperson - Freedom Under law

If you go to court, you win or you lose. If you lose you can go on appeal.

Judge Johann Kriegler, Chairperson - Freedom Under law

It is not proper or responsible for a political party to attack the good faith of the court on a racial basis, that is destroying our ability to be able to live with one another.

Judge Johann Kriegler, Chairperson - Freedom Under law

He says sound logical arguments rather than anger would be a far better path for a political party such as the EFF to take.

He believes there is more to the party than just race-baiters and name-callers, arguing there are some good people within the EFF who have made positive contributions to the debates.

Regarding Monday's outcome, Kriegler says it is not proper for a judge to comment on a judgment that is on appeal.

But if you are going to ask for an urgent interdict against somebody, you have to persuade the court that you will suffer irreparable harm.

Judge Johann Kriegler, Chairperson - Freedom Under law

He says Judge Potterill had to deal with the merits of the attack on the so-called Sars rogue unit and he sees nothing wrong in that.

To criticise her on that basis is legally not justifiable.

Judge Johann Kriegler, Chairperson - Freedom Under law

Listen to Judge Kriegler's views below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : 'EFF attack on good faith of court is extremely dangerous and deplorable'


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

The final episode of Deon Wiggett's podcast series 'My Only Story' has been published in collaboration with News24.

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

The District Six Reference Group will hold a meeting on Saturday to outline the proposals that the government has put on the table.

Is southern Africa drought drying up Victoria Falls?

Is southern Africa drought drying up Victoria Falls?

Harare-based BBC journalist Shingai Nyoka gives a first-hand account of the devastating effect of the drought on Zimbabwe.

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

PayFast MD Jonathan Smit says the spread of technologies available should help mitigate risk of compromising payment systems.

'Mkhwebane's Eskom IPP probe is a spurious act designed to slow things down'

'Mkhwebane's Eskom IPP probe is a spurious act designed to slow things down'

EE Publishers MD and editor Chris Yelland analyses the Public Protector's investigation into the power utility.

Court rules in favour of Gordhan, Mkhwebane slapped with cost order

Court rules in favour of Gordhan, Mkhwebane slapped with cost order

EWN reporter Barry Bateman discusses the high court judgment favouring Public Enterprise Minister Pravin Gordhan.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] Centre for the Less Good Idea keeps the arts alive during lockdown

[LISTEN] Centre for the Less Good Idea keeps the arts alive during lockdown

The centre is an interdisciplinary incubator space for the arts based in Maboneng, Johannesburg.

[WATCH] LeadSA applauds frontline heroes running with the baton

[WATCH] LeadSA applauds frontline heroes running with the baton

LeadSA applauds everyday heroes standing in the frontlines making a difference in communities.

Informal traders confused about lockdown regulations

Informal traders confused about lockdown regulations

City of Cape Town says the process of issuing permits to informal food traders only applies to those selling uncooked foods.

[LOCKDOWN] Alcohol and cigarette ban costing SA billions - Justice Project SA

[LOCKDOWN] Alcohol and cigarette ban costing SA billions - Justice Project SA

Chairperson Howard Dembovsky says for both we are losing about R135-million per day in levies and revenues.

Protective gear: 'There's trust breakdown between government and public sector'

Protective gear: 'There's trust breakdown between government and public sector'

Nehawu has filed urgent court papers against the Department of Health for failure to protect workers during COVID-19 outbreak.

Scopa chairperson warns government against corruption during COVID-19

Scopa chairperson warns government against corruption during COVID-19

Mkhuleko Hlengwa has expressed his concerns about the potential corrupt activities that may occur amidst the coronavirus.

East London prison officials awaiting COVID-19 results in self-isolation

East London prison officials awaiting COVID-19 results in self-isolation

Correctional Services spokesperson Singabakho Nxumalo says a female official tested positive after attending a funeral.

What needs to be achieved for the national lockdown to be lifted?

What needs to be achieved for the national lockdown to be lifted?

NICD's professor Cheryl Cohen says there will be a need for some kind of social distancing measures to be put in place.

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson battles COVID-19 in intensive care unit

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson battles COVID-19 in intensive care unit

Johnson tested positive for coronavirus 11 days ago.

[WATCH] Brothers creating a movie drive in experience in their garage goes viral

[WATCH] Brothers creating a movie drive in experience in their garage goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.