15042019 District Six 2019 03

Former minister slapped with personal costs order in District Six ruling

In yet another high-profile personal costs order, the Land Claims Court has ruled that former minister of Rural Development and Land Reform, Maite Nkoana-Mashabane did not comply with a court order to provide a proper plan to redevelop Cape Town's District Six.

It found that she did not adhere to a November court ruling which ordered her to come up with a restitution plan.

RELATED: ConCourt dismisses Mkhwebane's appeal against Bankorp costs order

District Six land claimants took Nkoana-Mashabane and her department to court after they missed their February deadline.

RELATED: Will Rural Development Department meet District Six resolution plan deadline?

John Maytham gets comment from Chris Todd, head of the dispute resolution department at law firm, Bowmans.

The court is dealing with a situation where what was not complied with wasn't just an ordinary obligation that a minister or a public official has, it was an obligation imposed by a court order.

Chris Todd, Head of dispute resolution department - Bowmans

However, Todd does warn against slapping potentially ruinous personal cost orders on public officials who are acting in good faith as opposed to those deliberately abusing their office.

In those circumstances it would be considered quite harsh to impose the cost on them of effectively doing what they believe to be the best job possible for the government or in the public interest.

Chris Todd, Head of dispute resolution department - Bowmans

What I think courts are particularly reacting against, and perhaps they are reflecting public sentiment along these lines, is public officials who are quite happy to litigate over and over again... because someone else is always paying for it.

Chris Todd, Head of dispute resolution department - Bowmans

For more on this argument, click on the link below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Former minister slapped with personal costs order in District Six ruling


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Senior citizen 'Ruth' called in to the John Maytham show to say a Sars office was depleted after announcement of union meeting.

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

EWN's Kaylynn Palm reports on Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula's presser after 18 carriages burnt out at Cape Town Station.

Recreational lobster fishing: 'Brochure two-seasons-old but still applies'

Recreational lobster fishing: 'Brochure two-seasons-old but still applies'

Fisheries Management's Wendy West clarifies questions around the current West Coast rock lobster recreational fishing season.

Financial Mail and amaBhungane head to court to obtain Zuma's tax records

Financial Mail and amaBhungane head to court to obtain Zuma's tax records

Financial Mail journalist Warren Thompson explains the motivation for the court application.

ConCourt dismisses Mkhwebane's appeal against Bankorp costs order

ConCourt dismisses Mkhwebane's appeal against Bankorp costs order

The Constitutional Court has dismissed Advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s appeal against a personal costs order.

Will Rural Development Department meet District Six resolution plan deadline?

Will Rural Development Department meet District Six resolution plan deadline?

The department has been given seven days to update a high court on progress regarding restitution to hundreds of land claimants.

Popular articles
 Eskom buys fine coal that looks like baby powder when wet, says expert Ted Blom

Eskom buys fine coal that looks like baby powder when wet, says expert Ted Blom

Energy analyst Ted Blom weighs in on the energy crisis in South Africa as load shedding stage 2 is implemented.

Want to get rich? Got R100? You don’t need millions to start

Want to get rich? Got R100? You don’t need millions to start

Bruce Whitfield interviews Anthea Gardner, author of "Make Your Money Work for You: Think Big, Start Small".

What is a 'Modern African Gentlemen'? Mini SA asks a 'pretentious' question

What is a 'Modern African Gentlemen'? Mini SA asks a 'pretentious' question

Branding and advertising expert Andy Rice hates Mini South Africa’s new "Clubman Modern African Gentlemen Edition".

MultiChoice dumps all Steve Hofmeyr content from its platforms

MultiChoice dumps all Steve Hofmeyr content from its platforms

The pay-TV company has taken a decision not to air any past or future content containing the Afrikannas singer.

[WATCH] Iceland’s Christmas advert banned- for being too political

[WATCH] Iceland’s Christmas advert banned- for being too political

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

City of Joburg explains R270 bill for pre-service termination notices

City of Joburg explains R270 bill for pre-service termination notices

Joburg MMC for finance responds to 702 callers complaints about these bills and how residents can apply for refunds.

How technology has impacted and affected the banking sector

How technology has impacted and affected the banking sector

The Banking sector has evolved. Customers can do transactions from the comfort of their own homes, saving them time and money.