sandf4jpg

'SANDF deployment a rallying point for communities to start own operations'

It's been more than two weeks since the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) was deployed to ten gang-riddled areas around Cape Town.

There have been mixed reports about the effectiveness of this attempt to help police stabilise these crime hot-spots and last weekend, at least 40 people were killed on the Cape Flats.

RELATED: Police corruption: Back to business as usual when army rolls out of Cape Flats?

Dr Simon Howell, research director at the African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum (Apcof) says while, at least for a time, there has been a decrease in serious or violent crime, it's difficult to judge whether this is because of the army presence or the mass deployment of police.

The military hasn't come alone in the sense that there have also been quite a large number of operations going on.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

We'll only really be able to figure it out retrospectively, in three months' time.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

RELATED: Bonteheuwel: Zero gang-related murders for an entire month

In the case of Bonteheuwel, residents themselves have reported that there has not been a single gang-related murder since the deployment.

Dr Howell believes, in turn, that the most effective contribution by the army has been to become a rallying point for people to begin their own community policing operations.

Bonteheuwel is a very special case in the sense that a lot of that massive decrease in crime is a result of community security officers that have been deployed.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

I would argue that it's not specifically the military that has done this great work, but actually the community itself rallying together, using the military deployment as a sort of starting premise and doing the job themselves.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

Asked about the reported increase in arrests over the last few weeks, Howell says it's very difficult to link this directly with gangsterism.

There has been an increase in arrests as a function of the resulting deployment of both the military and the various police units.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

As to whether these are sustainable I'm not sure. Whether these are specifically about gangs or whether they're actually just mopping-up operations in terms of general crime, it's again, quite hard to tell.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

In that case, is three months enough time for the Western Cape government to refine its own ongoing plans for a successful long-term crime-fighting strategy in these hot spots?

If the deployment acts as a point on which people can then make an effort to deal with gangsterism in the long term, then I would say that there was some success in the military deployment.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

In terms of the military deployment itself I wouldn't encourage it to remain on the ground occupying places because the military is ultimately the response to gangsterism and it's never going to deal with the actual issues at play as to why gangsterism continues to exist.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

The long-term plans would have to be far more encompassing than just law enforcement - you've got to deal with the reasons why people find gangs attractive in the first place.

Dr Simon Howell, Research director - African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum

Listen to the conversation here:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : 'SANDF deployment a rallying point for communities to start own operations'


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Bonteheuwel: Zero gang-related murders for an entire month

Bonteheuwel: Zero gang-related murders for an entire month

Bonteheuwel activist Henriette Abrahams says robberies have spiked because gangs are being prevented from selling drugs.

'Expectations on SANDF deployment were overinflated,'  says expert

'Expectations on SANDF deployment were overinflated,' says expert

Gangsterism continues to grip areas such as Mitchells Plain, Manenberg and Elsies River despite the presence of the army.

Kids can play in the streets now - SANDF deployment one week on

Kids can play in the streets now - SANDF deployment one week on

EWN reporter Kaylynn Palm unpacks the impact of the army patrolling in gang-stricken Cape Town communities.

Police corruption: Back to business as usual when army rolls out of Cape Flats?

Police corruption: Back to business as usual when army rolls out of Cape Flats?

UWC law lecturer Cherith Sanger says the temporary SANDF deployment is not going to affect issues that drive gangsterism and police collusion.

'The plan is going very well and SANDF soldiers are on the ground'

'The plan is going very well and SANDF soldiers are on the ground'

Premier Alan Winde and defence force spokesperson Mafi Mgobozi weigh in on the troops' deployment in Western Cape.

[VIDEOS AND PHOTOS] SANDF troops finally roll into the Cape Flats

[VIDEOS AND PHOTOS] SANDF troops finally roll into the Cape Flats

Residents were out on the streets to watch the troops arriving in Manenberg and Hanover Park on Thursday afternoon.

SANDF explains why it took a week to deploy troops to Cape Flats

SANDF explains why it took a week to deploy troops to Cape Flats

Secretary of Defence Dr Sam Gulube explains the preparation undertaken before soldiers could be deployed to the area.

Popular articles
Seize this opportunity to make Eskom board fit for purpose

Seize this opportunity to make Eskom board fit for purpose

“ Government must ensure that state-owned entities have boards with the right mix of skills to fulfil their mandates."

When will the broken internet cables be fixed?

When will the broken internet cables be fixed?

Damaged undersea cables frustrated many SA internet users this week. We get an update on the situation - and a backup plan.

How will Brexit affect UK trade with Africa?

How will Brexit affect UK trade with Africa?

The UK-Africa summit is underway and after Brexit, the UK reportedly wants to boost trade with our continent.

Gauteng to review school outing rules to guarantee pupils' safety

Gauteng to review school outing rules to guarantee pupils' safety

There have been concerns around the safety of learners at school camps following the death of 13-year-old Enoch Mpianzi.

Recruitment firm partners with Uber to give youth free transport to interviews

Recruitment firm partners with Uber to give youth free transport to interviews

Trusted Interns says access to transport is a huge barrier for unemployed youth to access the job market.

Meet the quiz mastermind behind the Dischem Brain of 702 competition

Meet the quiz mastermind behind the Dischem Brain of 702 competition

Azania Mosaka speaks to the man tasked with designing the Brain of 702 quizzes - writer Dawid Van Lill.

Transport to be offered to Ekhamanzi Primary learners crossing river to school

Transport to be offered to Ekhamanzi Primary learners crossing river to school

KwaZulu-Natal MEC for Education Kwazi Mshengu they are struggling with the budget for scholar transport.

Ella Morrison of Roedean School rated top debater in the country

Ella Morrison of Roedean School rated top debater in the country

Morrison spoke to Joanne Joseph on the Afternoon Drive about the skill and the work that goes into it.

 Inquest into anti-apartheid activist Neil Aggett's death gets underway

Inquest into anti-apartheid activist Neil Aggett's death gets underway

Aggett, a doctor and trade unionist born on 6 October 1953, died in 1982 in police custody under mysterious circumstances.

Ramaphosa signs money bills into law

Ramaphosa signs money bills into law

Eyewitness News parliamentary correspondent Babalo Ndenze gives details about the bills.