[LISTEN] Understanding the decision to set aside the Seriti commission findings

On Wednesday, the High Court in Pretoria found the Seriti commission failed to comprehensively investigate the arms deal as it had been mandated to do.

The commission, chaired by Judge Willie Seriti, ran for four years and cost taxpayers more than R130m.

Sizwe Mpofu-Walsh, standing in for Eusebius McKaiser, spoke to author and Corruption Watch senior investing officer Paul Holden as well as director of Open Secrets and author Hennie van Vuuren to unpack the case and the implications of this review.

The key issues were one were there procurement irregularities in this deal where mistakes made. Was the process manipulated? The second was to investigate allegations of corruption and the last thing which is a slightly technical but important thing was that the commission was supposed to look into whether the offsets ever materialised.

Paul Holden, Senior investing officer - Corruption Watch

Unfortunately the commission investigated none of those, which is a huge tragedy because it was the first time there was ever an independent possibility of the arms deal being investigated fully. For the commission to have conducted itself like this is a great tragedy.

Paul Holden, Senior investing officer - Corruption Watch

Van Vuuren says the high court judgment is a victory for civil society.

Over 40 civil society organisations said that this is effectively a whitewash, a cover-up and that witnesses should withdraw.

Hennie van Vuuren, Director - Open Secrets

I think the outcome at some point was something that was predetermined and I think that is again the importance of Justice [Dunstan] Mlambo's judgment last week is to send a message that this kind of conduct can never be repeated in South Africa.

Hennie van Vuuren, Director - Open Secrets

Click on the link below to hear the full conversation...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Panyaza Lesufi: Within the next 48 hours I will act on Parktown Boys' High

Panyaza Lesufi: Within the next 48 hours I will act on Parktown Boys' High

The Gauteng MEC for Education gives an account of what he saw when he got to the camp where Enoch drowned.

Parktown Boys' High pupil: The headmaster emphasised we must not speak to anyone

Parktown Boys' High pupil: The headmaster emphasised we must not speak to anyone

A grade 8 learner recalls in graphic detail how he and other boys watched Enoch Mpianzi being swept away by water.

How do we build school institutional cultures that are healthy for boys?

How do we build school institutional cultures that are healthy for boys?

Eusebius McKaiser speaks to child psychologist Dr Shaheda Omar and The Character Company founder Jaco van Schalkwyk.

[LISTEN] How to respond to views you disagree with during public debate

[LISTEN] How to respond to views you disagree with during public debate

Eusebius McKaiser chats to UCT critical thinking lecturer Jacques Rousseau on the two aspects of critical thinking.

No life jackets found at Nyati Bush and Riverbreak where Enoch drowned - police

No life jackets found at Nyati Bush and Riverbreak where Enoch drowned - police

North West police spokesperson Colonel Adéle Myburgh says an initial autopsy on Enoch Mpianzi was conducted this morning.

[LISTEN] Taking charge of your emotions

[LISTEN] Taking charge of your emotions

Eusebius McKaiser speaks to clinical psychologist Jeanie Cave.

Popular articles
Yves Saint Laurent starts selling designer condoms for R95 a pop

Yves Saint Laurent starts selling designer condoms for R95 a pop

Some things in life just don’t need a “designer” counterpart, reckons branding and advertising expert Andy Rice.