The Science Of ...

Unsure where you stand on NHI? Experts slug it out in an emotional debate…

Doctor (pixabay.com, 2019)

We don’t say private security must be banned… This is mumbo-jumbo… it’s all garbage. The reality is we deal with a state that is not capable… We need policies that make sense in our reality…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

We had a terrible nine years… we need to start charting a path to shared prosperity… access to health can do that…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

(Also, read: 'NHI dropped on us like a dog dropping a huge, stinking turd in your kitchen!')

Government is working on a National Health Insurance (NHI) system for South Africa.

NHI aims to provide equal access to healthcare for all South Africans.

Philosophically, many South Africans seem to support NHI but fear it’s unworkable and poses an existential threat to the well-functioning private healthcare system.

There’s also the threat of corruption.

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield hosted a debate on NHI.

He asked Paul Theron (MD at Vestact Asset Management) and Russell Rensburg (Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy at University of the Witwatersrand) to slug it out.

Listen to the debate in the audio below (and scroll down for more quotes from it).

We need to de-commodify health…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

There’s a big trust deficit…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

It’s not going to pass Constitutional muster… Russel, you realise this thing is going to fail?

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

I fail to see why wealthier individuals… should be prevented… you’re going to ruin healthcare…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

70% of our specialists work in the private sector… It’s probably the state’s fault…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

If you want public health services to improve, run it better… The provinces that don’t work are those that are run by corrupt ANC administrations… A collapsing state system that is trying to cover up its faults…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

You get a much better level of private care in this country than you get from the NHS in the UK.

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

This thing could have a fantastic upside for hospital groups…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

We’re taking a bit of a gamble here…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

If the government is serious… they would turn it over to the private sector… Wasting money… rank corruption… but somehow, we think it’s a clever idea…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

The government doesn't have any more money… This thing is going to fail…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

Enjoy The Money Show, but miss it sometimes?

Get the best bits emailed to you daily, right after it ends:

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Canadian drinks Red Bull without getting wings. Sues Red Bull – and wins!

Canadian drinks Red Bull without getting wings. Sues Red Bull – and wins!

The company has agreed to settle. Because it said Red Bull gives you wings, and it doesn’t. Oh, Canada!

Tito Mboweni publishes evidence-based plan to fix structure of broken economy

Tito Mboweni publishes evidence-based plan to fix structure of broken economy

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield asks Peter Attard Montalto (Head of Capital Markets Research at Intellidex) for comment.

'NHI dropped on us like a dog dropping a huge, stinking turd in your kitchen!'

'NHI dropped on us like a dog dropping a huge, stinking turd in your kitchen!'

NHI is “completely and utterly unworkable”, warns Vestact MD Paul Theron. “It’s NOT going to be f***ing fine!” he says.

'Tax revolt may be imminent. We must unapologetically recapture the State'

'Tax revolt may be imminent. We must unapologetically recapture the State'

Years of corruption and State Capture make some taxpayers feel morally justified to commit tax fraud, warns Edward Kieswetter.

I love the people. They might not love me – Randall Abrahams (SA Idols judge)

I love the people. They might not love me – Randall Abrahams (SA Idols judge)

Idols SA’s "angry judge" Randall Abrahams talks about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

Dead men tell no tales – Adriaan Basson (author of 'Blessed by Bosasa')

Dead men tell no tales – Adriaan Basson (author of 'Blessed by Bosasa')

Gavin Watson knew a lot. But now the story that shook SA and the ANC to its core will never be complete, says Adriaan Basson.

Popular articles
 Wealth strategies for small businesses - income or equity?

Wealth strategies for small businesses - income or equity?

Income or equity – what is the difference?

Is the US stock market heading for a crash like the DotCom bubble in 2000?

Is the US stock market heading for a crash like the DotCom bubble in 2000?

The US market has a big impact on all markets and when they get flu, South Africa sneezes.

Anglo American delivers 3.5-billion USD profit, declares final dividend

Anglo American delivers 3.5-billion USD profit, declares final dividend

Anglo American delivered a 2019 profit attributable to equity shareholders of 3.5-billion USD

Discovery Bank gives an update on the health of the new venture

Discovery Bank gives an update on the health of the new venture

Discovery is soothing investors' nerves after a warning earlier this week that it would report a double digits loss.

iPhone upgrade locks Absa clients out of banking app

iPhone upgrade locks Absa clients out of banking app

Absa managing executive customer value management Christine Wu explains why and how you can solve it.

Mo Shaik says his resignation is merely 'technical', not a result of DA pressure

Mo Shaik says his resignation is merely 'technical', not a result of DA pressure

He has dismissed the Democratic Alliance's claims that he was pressured to resign as as a special advisor to Lindiwe Sisulu.

Uber drivers' earnings dropped drastically since 2013 - Competition Commission

Uber drivers' earnings dropped drastically since 2013 - Competition Commission

The observation was made in a preliminary report into land-based public passenger transport by the commission.

City of Joburg libraries shortlisted for international award

City of Joburg libraries shortlisted for international award

COJ Library and Information Services director Nobuntu Mpendulo says they attract the youth by using electronic devices.

Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for Sona abuse claims

Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for Sona abuse claims

The president also apologised to South Africans about the way in which the gender-based violence matter was debated.

[LISTEN] Facebook group provides support for parents raising teens

[LISTEN] Facebook group provides support for parents raising teens

Azania Mosaka spoke to admin and media consultant of the page Vanessa Raphaely.