[LISTEN] 'Death penalty would not reduce violence in SA,' says Dennis Davis

A petition started on 2 September calling for the death penalty to be reinstated in South Africa has so far garnered more than 70,000 signatures.

However, on Wednesday the Justice Department issued a statement dismissing calls for a referendum on bringing back capital punishment.

With emotions running high in the country following the recent brutal murderers of several women, including University of Cape Town student Uyinene Mrwetyana, many people believe the return of the death penalty will curb the increasing violence.

However, Judge Dennis Davis says that's not the case.

Even if we bought back the death penalty, it is not highly unlikely, it is absolutely improbable that the sort of violence we see engulfing South Africa right now would be reduced in any measurable form.

Judge Dennis Davis

Davis says while petitions like the one started on Monday, may point towards a tide of feeling in the country, he adds that the point of the Bill of Rights is that certain issues are put beyond the reach of the transient majority.

Of course, I understand this notion of 'the people say so', but the answer is, that isn't the model we have. Just look at what a referendum did to England...it utterly and completely destroyed that society.

Judge Dennis Davis

Capital punishment was abolished in South Africa in 1995 by the Constitutional Court in the landmark case of S v Makwanyane and Another.

Listen to the full interview:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : [LISTEN] 'Death penalty would not reduce violence in SA,' says Dennis Davis


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Emasculation' of men contributes to SA's high murder rate

'Emasculation' of men contributes to SA's high murder rate

The 2018/19 crime statistics were released today and reveal Nyanga in Cape Town as the murder captial of the country.

Here's why a merger for SAA, Mango and SA Express would be a disaster

Here's why a merger for SAA, Mango and SA Express would be a disaster

SA Flyer Magazine's Guy Leitch says while in some ways it may be cost-effective, the merger itself would be very expensive.

[LISTEN] What actually works in reducing cases of GBV?

[LISTEN] What actually works in reducing cases of GBV?

CapeTalk's John Maytham asks which interventions are proven to work in reducing GBV.

Top tips for keeping your furry friends cool in summer

Top tips for keeping your furry friends cool in summer

Veterinarian Roy Aronson shares some of his top tips on caring for your pets during the warmer months.

SABC news chief must take fall for Ramaphosa clip sabotage, says CWU

SABC news chief must take fall for Ramaphosa clip sabotage, says CWU

The public broadcaster says it has evidence that the airing of the unedited clip had been an act of sabotage.

Ninow looked for someone to attack - state argues intention of Dros rape accused

Ninow looked for someone to attack - state argues intention of Dros rape accused

Earlier this week Ninow pleaded guilty to two counts of rape, possession of drugs and defeating the ends of justice.

Popular articles
[WATCH] Young boy's school concert dance moves delights Twitter

[WATCH] Young boy's school concert dance moves delights Twitter

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

What is better - money in the bank or investing in shares?

What is better - money in the bank or investing in shares?

Personal finance expert Warren Ingram offers a definitive answer with an explanation ordinary people can understand.

KZN bishop Timothy Ngcobo stands by xenophobic remarks

KZN bishop Timothy Ngcobo stands by xenophobic remarks

The well-known religious leader has allegedly been put under surveillance by KZN police for fueling xenophobic sentiments.

Nando’s is the boss of Pick n Pay ('iNkukhu'),  says ad expert Andy Rice

Nando’s is the boss of Pick n Pay ('iNkukhu'), says ad expert Andy Rice

“Pick n Pay dug themselves a hole, then jumped into it,” says branding and advertising expert Andy Rice.

EWN's Barry Bateman caught on camera calling Julius Malema a  P***, EWN responds

EWN's Barry Bateman caught on camera calling Julius Malema a P***, EWN responds

Twitter was abuzz after EWN reporter used the P after a press briefing with Economic Freedom Fighters leader.

Caller: 'Jehovah's Witness parents refused blood transfusion and child died

Caller: 'Jehovah's Witness parents refused blood transfusion and child died

Caller Harry describes how his anaesthetist dad once lost a child on the operating table after the parents refused a transfusion.

Nando's response to Pick n Pay 'iNkukhu' advert has social media in stitches

Nando's response to Pick n Pay 'iNkukhu' advert has social media in stitches

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Nigeria calls for sanctions against South Africa

Nigeria calls for sanctions against South Africa

"Enough is enough," said the Nigerian government in an official statement.