190905ramaphosajpg

Making sex offenders register public will give only 'false sense of security'

One of the measures put forward by President Cyril Ramaphosa in his pre-recorded address to the nation on Thursday evening to address the epidemic of violence against women and children, is to overhaul the national register for gender-based violence offenders.

This includes asking Parliament to make the register public.

RELATED: [WATCH] Violence against women is not a woman's problem - Ramaphosa

But would this really have an impact?

Activist and researcher Lisa Vetten says the problem is too urgent for the state to be investing time and money in measures that research shows are not effective.

There is no research in the countries where public sex offenders registers have been created, that they've had any effect whatsoever.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

It is one of those measures that gives us a sense of security, that looks and seems in terms of our common sense to make a difference, but I think it's a measure that gives us false security because ultimately it doesn't work.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

She emphasizes that the register itself has a place, in terms of alerting those who employ others to work with children and people with intellectual disabilities to offenders in these categories.

Why the Law Commission didn't extend this more broadly is because there isn't a lot of evidence for these measures having broader impact.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

So we would be putting a lot of time, a lot of money, a lot of human resources into something that simply does not work.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

On the calls for introducing chemical castration of rapists, Vetten has this to say:

The fundamental point is that the act of rape is not an act of uncontrollable, excessive hormone production. It is a problem of what goes on inside your head.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

This problem is far too serious and far too urgent for us to be wasting time and money on things that don't work, although they make us feel better.

Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research

Among the priority areas that could have more of an impact she says are getting proper statistics and researching them to determine patterns of behaviour and finding out why protection orders are not working.

Listen to the thought-provoking conversation here:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Making sex offenders register public will give only 'false sense of security'


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Ramaphosa's use of a recorded message was not a good idea - Wits professor

Ramaphosa's use of a recorded message was not a good idea - Wits professor

Ivor Sarakinsky says the president could have handled an emotional issue such as the gender-based violence protest better.

Martin Myers and Sipho Mabuse say: ENOUGH is ENOUGH

Martin Myers and Sipho Mabuse say: ENOUGH is ENOUGH

The Musix Exchange officials give their views and solutions to tackle gender-based violence in South Africa.

[WATCH] Violence against women is not a woman's problem -  Ramaphosa

[WATCH] Violence against women is not a woman's problem - Ramaphosa

The President addressed the public from Parliament on Thursday, in reaction to the latest scourge of gender-based violence.

EDITORIAL: Why we're not working today

EDITORIAL: Why we're not working today

For decades, SA women have been crying out for help, pleading for the war against us to end. Today, the women of Primedia Broadcasting take a stand.

Police task team on SA femicide long overdue, says activist Lisa Vetten

Police task team on SA femicide long overdue, says activist Lisa Vetten

Gender activist and researcher Lisa Vetten discusses the murder of women in South Africa and what can be done to effect change.

'I feel suffocated in South Africa' - learners protest outside Parliament

'I feel suffocated in South Africa' - learners protest outside Parliament

CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies has spoken to some young pupils from Cape Town High School speaking out against gender-based violence.

Popular articles
'Extreme concerns' about coronavirus making landfall in Africa

'Extreme concerns' about coronavirus making landfall in Africa

The coronavirus has made landfall - and apart from obvious dangers, its effect on the Chinese economy will also hit Africa hard.

An Allan Gray advertisement hits home and a golf resort gets lost

An Allan Gray advertisement hits home and a golf resort gets lost

Andy Rice, branding and advertising expert, tells us what ads caught his fancy and which ones baffled him.

Why EY thinks it's time to start dropping SA’s corporate tax rate

Why EY thinks it's time to start dropping SA’s corporate tax rate

If the corporate tax rate in South Africa gets lowered, would it lead to higher tax collections?

Stats SA Council threatens to resign over lack of funding, frozen posts

Stats SA Council threatens to resign over lack of funding, frozen posts

''If there are no official statistics approved by the statistician general - at that point I think your rates agencies will just say Game Over.''

Gauteng Transport Department to offer taxi drivers advanced driving lessons

Gauteng Transport Department to offer taxi drivers advanced driving lessons

MEC Jacob Mamabolo says a pilot study with Putco buses on Moloto road and there has been some improvement.

'Are you abusing your wife?' Mamabolo asks Malema in Parly

'Are you abusing your wife?' Mamabolo asks Malema in Parly

Julius Malema was in full flight when he agreed to answer a question from ANC MP Boy Mamabolo.

Soweto Home of the Aged is in dire need of proper, regular maintenance - DA

Soweto Home of the Aged is in dire need of proper, regular maintenance - DA

Democratic Alliance Gauteng shadow MEC for social development Refiloe Ntsekhe has conducted an oversight inspection at the home.

Are power ships a sustainable solution to SA's electricity crisis?

Are power ships a sustainable solution to SA's electricity crisis?

Azania Mosaka speaks to Energize editor Roger Lilley to get his insights on this and whether it is a sustainable alternative.

Competition Commission announces car servicing and repair guidelines

Competition Commission announces car servicing and repair guidelines

Competition Commission head of communications Sipho Ngwema explains what they are trying to achieve with the guidelines.

Springboks named sports team of the year at 2020 Laureus Awards

Springboks named sports team of the year at 2020 Laureus Awards

Captain Siya Kolisi accepted the award at a ceremony in Berlin on Monday.