'Disappointing that Robert Mugabe remembered as revolutionary icon by leaders'

On Friday, Zimbabwean President Emmerson Mnangagwa declared Robert Mugabe a national hero, after his predecessor died in a Singapore hospital at the age of 95.

South Africa's Cyril Ramaphosa and Kenya's Uhuru Kenyatta were among the African leaders to pay tribute to Mugabe, who is both revered as a revolutionary icon and reviled as a ruthless dictator.

But how do Zimbabweans themselves feel about this mixed legacy?

RELATED: [BREAKING NEWS] Robert Mugabe (95) has died in Singapore

CapeTalk's Africa Melane gets the input of analyst and researcher Tamuka Chirimambowa, who is an associate at the Democracy Works Foundation (DWF).

While acknowledging Mugabe's role in the country's liberation struggle, Chirimambowa says a significant number of Zimbabweans feel he betrayed them.

He describes Mugabe's death as an 'akward' moment as people's various cultures require that they do not speak ill of the dead.

But deep down, people are saying 'a tyrant has gone'. Some people, on social media, have been brave enough to celebrate it.

Tamuka Chirimambowa, Associate - Democracy Works Foundation

When you look at the record of Robert Mugabe it evokes a number of emotions but I think what has been quite disappointing is when you look at Robert Mugabe - even in South Africa, Kenya, Uganda, you hear 'revolutionary icon' but actually this speaks to the pitfalls of national consciousness which you find across Africa.

Tamuka Chirimambowa, Associate - Democracy Works Foundation

Chirimambowa notes there are very few exceptions to the tendency of Africa's post-independence leaders to betray their people.

He says Mugabe cannot be compared to these exceptions, citing South Africa's Nelson Mandela and Zambia's Kenneth Kaunda as examples.

If you look at what happens post-independence, particularly around the human rights record, how Mugabe dealt with Zimbabweans right from the Matabele massacres to dealing with issues of opposition supporters - the killings, the disappearances, the torture - that brings a scar.

Tamuka Chirimambowa, Associate - Democracy Works Foundation

Was he interested in liberation or was he interested in getting into power for his own personal sake?

Tamuka Chirimambowa, Associate - Democracy Works Foundation

For more from Chirimambowa, take a listen:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : 'Disappointing that Robert Mugabe remembered as revolutionary icon by leaders'


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Is it even possible to lock down townships and informal settlements, asks Prof

Is it even possible to lock down townships and informal settlements, asks Prof

Professor Alex Broadbent (UJ) on his argument that a one-size-fits-all approach to Covid-19 could have lethal consequences.

'CT needs neighbourhood watches authorised to help enforce lockdown compliance'

'CT needs neighbourhood watches authorised to help enforce lockdown compliance'

JP Smith says Capetonians were largely cooperative on Day One of lockdown, but there were pockets of 'massive' non-compliance.

[BREAKING NEWS] Robert Mugabe (95) has died in Singapore

[BREAKING NEWS] Robert Mugabe (95) has died in Singapore

Mugabe’s successor President Emmerson Mnangagwa confirmed the news on Twitter on Friday morning.

 Amnesty International slams Mnangagwa over 'brutal crackdown on human rights'

Amnesty International slams Mnangagwa over 'brutal crackdown on human rights'

The human rights group says authorities in Zimbabwe have shown contempt for basic freedoms and intolerance for dissent.

Zimbabwe to reverse Mugabe's land seizures, will pay millions to white farmers

Zimbabwe to reverse Mugabe's land seizures, will pay millions to white farmers

Financial Mail deputy editor, Sikonathi Mantshantsha says the announcement sounds like a delayed April fool's joke.

'Zimbabweans are facing a much bigger and more complex problem than just fuel'

'Zimbabweans are facing a much bigger and more complex problem than just fuel'

Political analyst and researcher at Pesa says Zimbabweans expected there would be change after Mugabe, but there has been none.

Popular articles
Two elderly people die while queuing for grant payments - Sassa

Two elderly people die while queuing for grant payments - Sassa

An elderly woman is believed to have collapsed when she was confirmed dead outside a Pimville Post Office in Johannesburg.

Sassa grant recipients endure long queues to receive their payouts

Sassa grant recipients endure long queues to receive their payouts

Eyewitness News reporter Kevin Brandt says some recipients turned back on Monday, saying they would try again the next day.

Which farmers should benefit from emergency aid, and who will need it?

Which farmers should benefit from emergency aid, and who will need it?

Stellenbosch University professor of agricultural economics professor Johann Kirsten looks at who should benefit from this money.

[LISTEN] #Covid-19: Psychiatrist offers support service to healthcare workers

[LISTEN] #Covid-19: Psychiatrist offers support service to healthcare workers

Joanne Joseph spoke to psychiatrist Dr Claire Lownie about the pro-bono offering.

'Police shot at Vosloorus man in his veranda, unprovoked'

'Police shot at Vosloorus man in his veranda, unprovoked'

Eyewitness News reporter Theto Mahlakoane gives details of what the community members saw when the man was killed.

[LISTEN] Most people are suffering from 'corona panic syndrome' - expert

[LISTEN] Most people are suffering from 'corona panic syndrome' - expert

Wits University clinical pharmacologist Dr Mohamed Irhuma says people must spend less time on social media.

Business Partners Limited preparing to administer Rupert funding for SMEs

Business Partners Limited preparing to administer Rupert funding for SMEs

Gushwell Brooks speaks to business partner Ben Bierman about how these funds will be administered.

SABC disputes Bemawu's claim that the broadcaster concealed COVID-19 case

SABC disputes Bemawu's claim that the broadcaster concealed COVID-19 case

Bemawu has accused the SABC of endangering the lives of employees.

Social grant payouts have been going smoothly - Lindiwe Zulu

Social grant payouts have been going smoothly - Lindiwe Zulu

Social development minister says they are also keeping in touch with other provinces where there seems to be challenges.

[COVID-19] Tracing people in informal settlements will be a challenge

[COVID-19] Tracing people in informal settlements will be a challenge

Bhekisisa Centre for Health Journalism journalist Joan van Dyk says it is an emotional job to be a tracer.