Do South Africans hate fellow Africans? Pundits discuss

More than 400 people have been arrested for looting during xenophobia-related violence and the death toll is rising.

Is it xenophobia, Afrophobia or pure hatred?

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a conversation with Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) Gauteng provincial chairperson Amos Monyela, Commission for Governance & Politics for African Diaspora Forum chairman Ngqabutha Mabena and senior research specialist at Human Science Council of SA working in democracy & governance & service delivery research programme Dr Steven Gordon.

South Africans are not exhibiting afro hatred. They found themselves in a space where their socio-economic challenge have not been looked at by the powers that be and this is not a South African phenomenon. It is an African phenomenon where all African leaders are self-serving.

Amos Monyela, Gauteng provincial chairperson - Cosatu

RELATED: Criminality is fuelled by our hatred for fellow Africans, not fear - Eusebius

You are in a continent that is rich in minerals and agriculture but the mismanagement by the leadership of the continent is a problem. It creates this kind of a thing

Amos Monyela, Gauteng provincial chairperson - Cosatu

The discussion we are having currently we look into the criminality part of it and we are not looking into the main issues that cause the crisis that we find ourself in.

Amos Monyela, Gauteng provincial chairperson - Cosatu

Mabena says he has not really experienced hatred in the country over the years that he has been here.

There is this unity over the years among migrants and South Africans but then, yes, there are criminal elements and also the competition for resources in poor communities.

Ngqabutha Mabena, Chairman - Commission for Governance & Politics for African Diaspora Forum

The reality is that there are concerns that we must underline and there are genuine concerns in terms of the economic direction this country is taking. You have 30% unemployment, you have competition for little resources and you have thousands of migrants who are not documented, it is a reality.

Ngqabutha Mabena, Chairman - Commission for Governance & Politics for African Diaspora Forum

Dr Gordon warns against making simple binaries.

Many South Africans hold anti-immigrant views. They hold very negative views of immigration. They hold negative views of international migrant communities. Often these views have specific bias against certain African communities, the Nigerian, Somalian and Zimbabwean communities.

Dr Steven Gordon, Human Sciences Research Council

Listen to the full interview below...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[LISTEN] Unpacking the concept non-binary

[LISTEN] Unpacking the concept non-binary

Dr Eve breaks down some of the identities that are outside the gender binary.

'We tend to retire from something and what we should do is retire to something'

'We tend to retire from something and what we should do is retire to something'

Eusebius McKaiser and for 702 presenter John Robbie co-host an hour open line special.

Criminality is fuelled by our hatred for fellow Africans, not fear - Eusebius

Criminality is fuelled by our hatred for fellow Africans, not fear - Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser explains the difference between xenophobia and afro-hatred.

Ramaphosa's use of a recorded message was not a good idea - Wits professor

Ramaphosa's use of a recorded message was not a good idea - Wits professor

Ivor Sarakinsky says the president could have handled an emotional issue such as the gender-based violence protest better.

'WEF Africa may force SA government to pay attention to the issue of xenophobia'

'WEF Africa may force SA government to pay attention to the issue of xenophobia'

Business consultancy Africa At Work's chief executive Dianna Games gives her take ahead of this year's forum.

Why our leaders MUST acknowledge xenophobia in South Africa

Why our leaders MUST acknowledge xenophobia in South Africa

Police Minister Bheki Cele claims that xenophobia is being 'used as an excuse' for the current unrest in parts of Gauteng.

Popular articles
 'When languages are being let go of in favour of English, we lose identity'

'When languages are being let go of in favour of English, we lose identity'

Joanne Joseph spoke to Play Africa founder and CEO Gretchen Wilson-Prangley on International Language Day.

'There is a stated commitment to deal with TRC cases but it's taking too long'

'There is a stated commitment to deal with TRC cases but it's taking too long'

Former commissioner Yasmin Sooka says it has been a 16-year battle trying to get the NPA to prosecute TRC-related cases.

We have invested heavily in driver and passenger safety - Uber

We have invested heavily in driver and passenger safety - Uber

Uber Sub-Saharan Africa general manager Alon Lit says their prices have not changed drastically since 2013.

 Tegeta's R3.7-billion coal supply contract with Eskom set aside

Tegeta's R3.7-billion coal supply contract with Eskom set aside

SIU spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago says the court has given the unit the green light to institute legal action against the company.

Protesters torch two suspected drug dens in Parow over Tazne van Wyk killing

Protesters torch two suspected drug dens in Parow over Tazne van Wyk killing

Eyewitness News reporter Lizelle Persens gives an update from the protest in Parow.

[LISTEN]  Craig Urbani talks Rocky Horror and playing Frank-N-Furter

[LISTEN] Craig Urbani talks Rocky Horror and playing Frank-N-Furter

The actor and singer joined Azania Mosaka in studio for this week's Friday Profile.

[WATCH] Glimpse of Simon & Garfunkel Songbook performance

[WATCH] Glimpse of Simon & Garfunkel Songbook performance

Make sure you don't miss the Simon & Garfunkel Songbook national tour taking place in Johannesburg, Cape Town and Sasolburg.

Azania, Bongani queue for new model flip phone

Azania, Bongani queue for new model flip phone

PARTNER CONTENT: Samsung's new Galaxy Z Flip has South Africa, and our presenters, abuzz - and it launched in SA today!

Jacob Zuma is coming back to Mzansi, supporters told to gather at OR Tambo

Jacob Zuma is coming back to Mzansi, supporters told to gather at OR Tambo

Committee member of the Gauteng RET Zuma supporters Carl Niehaus says supporters must arrive before 10am.

Dudu Myeni 'unwilling to spend her money on delinquency case, feels targeted'

Dudu Myeni 'unwilling to spend her money on delinquency case, feels targeted'

Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse chief legal officer Advocate Stefanie Fick shares the latest.