'Data doesn't support that foreigners are grabbing jobs from South Africans'

The spike in violence against foreign nationals in parts of Gauteng in recent weeks was debated in the National Assembly on Tuesday.

Some Members of Parliament fingered government failure in safeguarding the country's borders and blamed the situation on undocumented immigrants. The defence minister insisted the soon to be implemented Border Management Authority bill will strengthen border security.

RELATED: Ten South Africans and two foreign nationals died, says defence minister

To discuss Tuesday's debate, Bongani Bingwa speaks to the African Centre for Migration Studies postdoctoral fellow Dr Rebecca Walker.

RELATED: 'This is criminality, criminals are taking advantage of SA's challenges'

Walker says there are only 3.6 million foreign nationals living in South Africa and the argument that the country is under siege due to poor borders and illegal migration is not supported by the data.

It is impossible that 7% of the population could be responsible for all of the problems we are currently facing in the country and even in Gauteng, only 7-8% of the province is made up of none nationals.

Dr Rebecca Walker, Postdoctoral fellow - African Centre for Migration Studies

She says migrant numbers are not the problem but rather lack of government leadership.

It is about deep routed disappointment and anger around a lack of jobs and services which then gets deflected on to foreign nationals who are a very easy scapegoat.

Dr Rebecca Walker, Postdoctoral fellow - African Centre for Migration Studies

Walker says politicians cannot blame the crisis in the South African health systems on foreign nationals.

The health system is in crisis anyway. It is down to planning, under-resourcing and even in areas where we don't have migrants, the health care system is crumbling.

Dr Rebecca Walker, Postdoctoral fellow - African Centre for Migration Studies

She says South Africans need to shift the narrative away from that which argues foreign nationals are taking away from South Africans and rather look at the opportunities they bring to the country.

When you have such high levels of inequality and poverty and you add foreign nationals into this competitive pool, you get everyone trying to get what is available. To suggest that foreign nationals are grabbing jobs from South Africans is not supported by the research.

Dr Rebecca Walker, Postdoctoral fellow - African Centre for Migration Studies

Listen below to the full interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[WATCH] Camera falling from plane into pig pen has social media in stitches

[WATCH] Camera falling from plane into pig pen has social media in stitches

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

Who actually owns this house, some social media users say it belongs to them

Who actually owns this house, some social media users say it belongs to them

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

[WATCH] SANDF tank crashing through crowd goes viral, is this another Mabena?

[WATCH] SANDF tank crashing through crowd goes viral, is this another Mabena?

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

Do South Africans hate fellow Africans? Pundits discuss

Do South Africans hate fellow Africans? Pundits discuss

Cosatu's Amos Monyela says the focus is on criminality instead of the main issues that cause the crisis that we find ourself in.

 'This is criminality, criminals are taking advantage of SA's challenges'

'This is criminality, criminals are taking advantage of SA's challenges'

Defence and Military Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula gives her views on the recent violence in the Johannesburg CBD.

Criminality is fuelled by our hatred for fellow Africans, not fear - Eusebius

Criminality is fuelled by our hatred for fellow Africans, not fear - Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser explains the difference between xenophobia and afro-hatred.

Popular articles
Meet the Black Management Forum's New President

Meet the Black Management Forum's New President

The newly elected president of the Black Management Forum (BMF) is Andile Nomlala.

Read your documents before you sign the deal on your car or house!

Read your documents before you sign the deal on your car or house!

Wendy Knowler, consumer journalist, on the importance of carefully reading your documents when you buy assets.

Finding your way after 15 years with Google Maps

Finding your way after 15 years with Google Maps

Google has not only indexed the internet, but they have also mapped the world

Annual consumer price inflation shot up at a rate of 4.5%  - should we worry?

Annual consumer price inflation shot up at a rate of 4.5% - should we worry?

Annual consumer price inflation increased at a faster rate of 4.5% in January, compared to 4% in December.

 Grand Parade Investments sells its interest in Burger King

Grand Parade Investments sells its interest in Burger King

South Africa's Grand Parade Investments (GPI) Ltd will sell its 95.36 percent stake in the Burger King franchise.

 Missing student Alfa Mpetsheni being held by Shanghai security bureau - mother

Missing student Alfa Mpetsheni being held by Shanghai security bureau - mother

Thuli Mpetsheni says she does not know the circumstances surrounding her son's detainment but it appears his visa has expired.

 Business rescue team 'still looking at possible plan to avoid SAA liquidation'

Business rescue team 'still looking at possible plan to avoid SAA liquidation'

SAA returned to Parliament on Wednesday to brief public finance watchdog Scopa on its state of affairs.

Resign or we will block the budget – Lesotho opposition tells Thabane

Resign or we will block the budget – Lesotho opposition tells Thabane

ABC leader and Lesotho Prime Minister Tom Thabane has announced twice that he will retire with no time specified.

We were acting in the member's best interest - Discovery Health

We were acting in the member's best interest - Discovery Health

Discovery Health CEO Dr Ryan Noach explains why they could not fund a valve implant called a Xen stent for a glaucoma patient.

Blame game as five provinces suffer contraceptive shortages

Blame game as five provinces suffer contraceptive shortages

Stop Stock Outs Project manager Kopano Klass explains the investigation they did to unearth this shortage of medicines.