Why new 'revenge porn' laws don't go far enough to protecting victims

A new law that seeks to clamp down on revenge porn and the distribution of child pornography is not without its flaws.

That's according to one of the country's leading media law experts.

On Wednesday, Emma Sadlier joined John Maytham to unpack the key provisions of the Films and Publications Amendment Act 11 of 2019.

Sadlier began by explaining how previously those who were victims of "revenge porn" would have been able to seek redress under criminal law.

I would have said go and lay a criminal charge of crimen injuria, which is a very general crime, it's when someone seriously infringes your dignity and you could sue for damages.

Emma Sadleir, Media law consultant

Section 18 of the bill explains what needs to be proven in order for someone to found guilty under the new legislation.

The content has to be exposed, through any medium (internet or social media), but then it says it has to be a private, sexual photograph.

Emma Sadleir, Media law consultant

Sadlier says that in this instance the, definitions of "private" and "sexual" are problematic.

I'm also worried about the requirement that you have to show an intention to cause that individual harm.

I think when we're dealing with this kind of content the standard should be negligence.

Emma Sadleir, Media law consultant

Listen to the full interview below:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Why new 'revenge porn' laws don't go far enough to protecting victims


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Sars office operated with skeleton staff to allow union meeting, says caller

Senior citizen 'Ruth' called in to the John Maytham show to say a Sars office was depleted after announcement of union meeting.

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

Why did security fail when CCTV cameras picked up train-fire suspects?

EWN's Kaylynn Palm reports on Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula's presser after 18 carriages burnt out at Cape Town Station.

'Revenge porn' law clamps down on non-consensual distribution of sexual content

'Revenge porn' law clamps down on non-consensual distribution of sexual content

Social media law expert Emma Sadleir explains what the signing of the Films and Publications Bill into law means.

You can get fined up to R300,000 for 'revenge porn'

You can get fined up to R300,000 for 'revenge porn'

Social media law expert Emma Sadleir says the new bill will burb the distribution of image-based violence on social media.

Therapists describes what scary 'consensual' sex looks like

Therapists describes what scary 'consensual' sex looks like

Clinical sexologist Dr Eve helps listeners understand what defines terrifying intercourse.

[LISTEN] Parenting the screenager

[LISTEN] Parenting the screenager

Social media law expert Emma Sadlier unpacks the kind of harm that can be caused when children have access to cellphones.

Popular articles
[WATCH] SA cop assisting angry Chinese national without passport goes viral

[WATCH] SA cop assisting angry Chinese national without passport goes viral

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

How removal of head of Chapter 9 institution, like Public Protector, would work

How removal of head of Chapter 9 institution, like Public Protector, would work

Parliamentary spokesperson Moloto Mothapo explains way forward after National Assembly's rules committee finalised draft rules.

'I believe I am the leader DA needs at this point in time' - Makashule Gana

'I believe I am the leader DA needs at this point in time' - Makashule Gana

The Gauteng MPL faces off against John Steenhuisen in the DA interim federal leader contest on Sunday.

Famous Brands (Steers, Debonairs, Wimpy, etc.) burned in UK, reports huge loss

Famous Brands (Steers, Debonairs, Wimpy, etc.) burned in UK, reports huge loss

An R874 million write-down in the UK burned Africa’s largest food franchisor. Bruce Whitfield interviews Darren Hele, its CEO.

Does God exist? A debate

Does God exist? A debate

Eusebius McKaiser hosted a heated debate on God's existence with atheist Jacques Rousseau and believer Mahlatse Winston Mashua.