School sex education: 'A one size fits all approach will not work'
The Department of Basic Education has rolled out a comprehensive sex education programme targeted at Grade 4 to Grade 12 pupils in South African schools.
The programme is aimed at teaching pupils about healthy lifestyles and sexual education.
There has been much debate around the programme.
Eusebius McKaiser chats to clinical sexologist Dr Eve, South Africa Teacher's Union professional advisor Maryna Besseling and Wits Institute for Diversity Studies researcher Dr Haley McEwen.
Dr Eve says comprehensive sex education is important because studies have shown the changes that have occurred from HIV incidences to unintended pregnancies throughout the years.
The picture is not pretty when one does a comparison from years ago to today, how the numbers just keep increasing. That tells us that whatever kind of intervention used in the current comprehensive sex education programmes is not really being effective.Dr Eve, Clinical sexologist and couples sex therapist
Besseling says the public has not yet seen the textbooks that the Department of Basic Education plans to distribute.
The department states that this component has been part of the Life Orientation curriculum since 2000. One would expect that if this component has been part of Life Orientation, there would be a drop in teenage pregnancies and there would be a drop in HIV infections, why is it not happening?Maryna Besseling, Professional advisor - South Africa Teacher's Union
She says there is now an extreme methodology of teaching.
The question is not whether children as young as 14 are having sex, but whether we provide them with the choice of choosing at what age they would like to get certain content.Maryna Besseling, Professional advisor - South Africa Teacher's Union
She says the community should have a choice.
Comprehensive sexuality education, not so much sex education is relevant. The question that arises is what is the level of exposure that will be provided - and at what age? Is it age-appropriate and is it contextual?Maryna Besseling, Professional advisor - South Africa Teacher's Union
If the context of the community is not taken into consideration, it will not work. There is diversity in the country and a one size fits all approach is not working.Maryna Besseling, Professional advisor - South Africa Teacher's Union
McEwen says there are dangerous effects of polarisation and discussions concerning sex education need to be held.
We need to find ways to talk about these issues and connect, however, I don't think there is a middle ground. Its either the one or the other.Dr Haley McEwen, Researcher - Wits Institute for Diversity Studies
She questions whether society can have a curriculum that is inclusive of gender and sexuality or not.
Listen below to the full conversation:
Health Minister Zweli Mkhize says the focus is on the establishment of committees at ward level and to also tackle the stigma.Read More
Bruce Whitfield interviews reps from the Restaurant Association Of SA, Business Unity SA and the National Liquor Traders Council.Read More
Liquor Traders Association of SA's Sean Robinson and Gauteng Liquor Forum's Fanny Mokoena reflect on liquor ban.Read More
Wits School of Governance's professor Alex van den Heever unpacks the latest restriction by the President Cyril Ramaphosa.Read More
President Cyril Ramaphosa said on Sunday he was concerned that South Africans were downplaying the seriousness of the pandemic.Read More
Ramaphosa addresses the nation this evening on developments in SA's risk-adjusted strategy to manage the spread of COVID-19.Read More
Provincial health department head Dr Thobile Mbengashe is adamant that these scooters were never meant to be ambulances.Read More
The company that got the R10 million tender's Brian Harmse sheds light on the controversial project.Read More
Clement Manyathela chats with former minister Malusi Gigaba in a new feature called #HangingOutwithClement.Read More
RMB CEO James Formby says if the country doesnt control its debt, it will find itself in an economic quagmire.Read More
The number of recoveries in South Africa so far is 146,279. The total number of tests conducted to date is 2.232,738.Read More
The couple are in isolation and the minister, who received his results earlier on Tuesday, will continue to work from home.Read More
Reatlile Blessing Tolo has been left wounded after she was viciously attacked by pit bulls.Read More
KwaZulu-Natal secretary Mandla Shabangu says the stigmatisation around the virus may be contributing to the problem.Read More
Spokesperson Wayne Minnaar says four were arrested on Allendale Road just before midnight busy consuming alcohol.Read More
The R153m draw took place on 10 July 2020. Ithuba's Busisiwe Msizi says buying tickets online has become popular.Read More
Forecaster Edward Engelbrecht says Gauteng is not going to experience as intense a weather as the Western Cape.Read More
Mandy Wiener speaks to clinical psychologist Ruth Ancer about some of the anxiety experienced in the face of COVID-19.Read More
Listeners express their frustrations with the service from Eskom on The Clement Manyethela Show.Read More
Justice ministry spokesperson Crispin Phiri explains the motive behind government's decision to enforce the wearing of masks.Read More