ConsumerTalk with Wendy Knowler

Beef mince or ground beef? A lesson on food labelling

Read the food label carefully before you buy your next pack of mince.

You may be getting a whole lot less meat for your money, says consumer journalist Wendy Knowler.

It's important to know the difference between minced beef and ground beef in South Africa.

Most retailers label pure, 100% mince as "beef mince" while the blended version is called "ground beef".

Pure beef mince contains no additives.

Ground beef, on the other hand, contains less meat, and more water and soya.

The price of ground beef is often much cheaper than minced beef, by between R10 and R30 a kg, Knowler reports.

She explains that industry refers to ground beef as an “extended” product for all the extra fillers that make it less expensive.

If you look at the ingredients list, it's very much not the same thing. Minced meat is meat, only. Ground beef is an "extended product", a lovely euphemism meaning that it's crammed with other much cheaper stuff to bulk it up.

Wendy Knowler, Consumer journalist

You're getting a whole lot less meat for your money than you think.

Wendy Knowler, Consumer journalist

While some of the food labelling on these meat products is misleading, it is not illegal.

The existing laws which regulate the definitions and contents of food products were repealed in May this year, leaving a gap for minced meat producers.

The government has not yet put in place the new definitions and criteria for food products, including raw processed meat, in the Foodstuffs, Cosmetics and Disinfectants Act.

RELATED: The truth about '100% fruit juice' and why food labelling matters

Draft regulations propose that ground beef must contain at least 70% meat. It may also contain edible offal, colourants and food additives.

However, the drafts state that no additives are permitted in raw minced meat.

RELATED: Beware: Your favourite dairy substitutes may contain milk

Consultant dietician Karen Horsburgh says while new legal distinctions will soon be required for manufacturers, not all consumers can tell the difference.

Some misleading food labels could possibly place consumers with food allergies at risk, Horsburgh explains.

While food labelling laws remain in limbo, Horsburgh says consumers who feel misled should refer to the Consumer Protection Act.

Food scientists Dr Francois Mellett says the confusing labels appear to be deliberately deceptive.

Meanwhile, retailers argue that ground beef exists to cater to customers who need an affordable source of protein.

Listen to the investigation and insightful discussion to learn more on #ConsumerTalk:

Every Wednesday, on The Pippa Hudson Show, Wendy Knowler provides useful insights and tips on how to make the most of your buying power.

For more stories visit the ConsumerTalk feature page.

Got a consumer case you need help resolving?

Email: consumer@knowler.co.za, put Cape Talk in the subject line, followed by the issue e.g. cellphone contract dispute.

Image: Pixabay.


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Beef mince or ground beef? A lesson on food labelling


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
When insurance claims go wrong

When insurance claims go wrong

Be mindful of what you're disclosing at the time you take out a policy.

Shoprite shrugs off reckless lending charges

Shoprite shrugs off reckless lending charges

Shoprite has been found guilty of reckless lending and fined. How serious do companies take such verdicts and fines though?

Check your debit orders!

Check your debit orders!

Interrogate your debit orders. They often encompass more payments than you think.

Only Germans take Black Friday more seriously than South Africans

Only Germans take Black Friday more seriously than South Africans

In South Africa, Black Friday has become a spend-fest of epic proportions, says consumer journalist Wendy Knowler.

We paid before the family arrived with the body – Old Mutual

We paid before the family arrived with the body – Old Mutual

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler investigates after a poor family’s desperation to get a claim paid made headlines.

'Fake cheese' on the menu? Wendy Knowler talks dairy product dupes

'Fake cheese' on the menu? Wendy Knowler talks dairy product dupes

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler says economic pressures on the dairy industry have driven costs up and affected production.

Popular articles
When insurance claims go wrong

When insurance claims go wrong

Be mindful of what you're disclosing at the time you take out a policy.

'Scrubbing' the atmosphere and other high-tech climate friendly innovations

'Scrubbing' the atmosphere and other high-tech climate friendly innovations

Data ssystems use a great deal of energy and tech providers must start reducing emissions.

How is 'steely' Pravin Gordhan coping under pressure from detractors?

How is 'steely' Pravin Gordhan coping under pressure from detractors?

Pravin Gordhan, the minister of public enterprises, wants to be left alone to do his job.

Naspers plans to sell shares in Prosus - will it decrease the Tencent gap?

Naspers plans to sell shares in Prosus - will it decrease the Tencent gap?

Naspers plans to sell about 22 million shares in Prosus - will it decrease the Tencent gap?

Davos 2020:  How well did Team South Africa pitch today?

Davos 2020: How well did Team South Africa pitch today?

Day two of Davos, where business heavyweights are attending the annual meeting of the World Economic Forum.

Callers detail how Northview High School learner died at Nyathi lodge in 1999

Callers detail how Northview High School learner died at Nyathi lodge in 1999

Lesego and Boitumelo detail in graphic detail how their schoolmate Portia died at the lodge while on a school trip.

Telkom meets unions over mass retrenchments

Telkom meets unions over mass retrenchments

Solidarity strategic specialist Morné Malan says the process is still continuing and very little progress has been made.

Two primary school pupils dead after truck crashes into wall

Two primary school pupils dead after truck crashes into wall

Officials said that a truck delivering food items at the school crashed into the wall.

Eskom appoints critic Sikonathi Mantshantsha as new spokesperson

Eskom appoints critic Sikonathi Mantshantsha as new spokesperson

Mantshantsha replaced Khulu Phasiwe who resigned in April last year from the embattled power utility.

Western Cape top judge accuses her boss John Hlope of assault, misconduct

Western Cape top judge accuses her boss John Hlope of assault, misconduct

EWN reporter Jason Felix gives insight on what this public spat between the two officials is all about.