ConCourt hears arguments in legal battle between Gordhan, Mkhwebane

On Thursday the Constitutional Court heard arguments around the power of courts to suspend the implementation of remedial action ordered by the Public Protector.

The apex court was approached by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane after a ruling against them by the High Court in Pretoria.

The High Court had granted Pravin Gordhan and President Cyril Ramaphosa an interim interdict against the remedial action Mkhwebane instructed Ramaphosa to take against the Minister of Public Enterprises.

The matter relates to the establishment of the so-called "rogue unit" within the South African Revenue Service (Sars).

RELATED: 'Recordings prove Moyane knew SARS unit wasn't rogue'

702's Joanne Joseph gets clarity from Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Foundation chair in Constitutional Governance at the University of Cape Town (UCT).

The constitutional law expert says at the heart of the case is the question of when a lower court should grant an interdict to halt the implementation of the Public Protector's remedial action, which is binding.

Is there a situation where the court will actually undermine the Public Protector if they give an interdict, or the opposite argument: What happens if the remedial action is implemented while there is a court case going on and then the case reviews and sets aside the remedial action, but then all the remedial action has already been implemented with negative impact on those affected?

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Foundation chair in Constitutional Governance - UCT

Professor de Vos says it is not an easy matter to decide.

Just because the judge has asked certain questions during the hearing doesn't mean that they will come out in a specific way. But judged by questions asked today, much more difficult questions were asked of the EFF and the Public Protector's lawyers than of the president and Mr Gordhan's lawyers.

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Foundation chair in Constitutional Governance - UCT

They were asking what exactly would be the harm to the Public Protector if she just waited until such time as the court case reviewing and deciding whether to set aside her report has been finalised.

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Foundation chair in Constitutional Governance - UCT

For more detail, take a listen to the audio in the clip below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight trustee Dr Matt Young says they get donations at the most time but now need big sponsors.

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

The Cato Manor 9 were hanged in 1961 by the apartheid after taking part in an uprising on 24 January 1960.

Festive season fatal crashes reduced by 3% as motorists heed safety calls

Festive season fatal crashes reduced by 3% as motorists heed safety calls

Eyewitness News reporter Kgomotso Modise gives a summary of the 2019/2020 road safety report.

Parktown Boys' High parent wants SGB, affected teachers and management charged

Parktown Boys' High parent wants SGB, affected teachers and management charged

The parent says the code of silence needs to be dismantled as boys who open their mouths are victimised and removed.

Callers detail how Northview High School learner died at Nyathi lodge in 1999

Callers detail how Northview High School learner died at Nyathi lodge in 1999

Lesego and Boitumelo detail in graphic detail how their schoolmate Portia died at the lodge while on a school trip.

Telkom meets unions over mass retrenchments

Telkom meets unions over mass retrenchments

Solidarity strategic specialist Morné Malan says the process is still continuing and very little progress has been made.

Popular articles
Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight trustee Dr Matt Young says they get donations at the most time but now need big sponsors.

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

The Cato Manor 9 were hanged in 1961 by the apartheid after taking part in an uprising on 24 January 1960.

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

The musician says he never writes songs about his personal life but this latest single is too personal for him.

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa acting director of communications Lusani Netshitomboni says they encourage students to register online.

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Mzwandile Stick has been reappointed as an assistant coach while in an innovative inclusion, Felix Jones will continue but in a new role as a European-based coaching consultant.

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Department of Minerals and Energy chief inspector of mine David Msiza says more needs to be done.

Parliament Speaker says yes to motion to start proceedings to remove PP

Parliament Speaker says yes to motion to start proceedings to remove PP

The fresh calls for Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s removal come after Parliament adopted new rules for the removal of a Public Protector.

 Lesufi suspends Parktown Boys' High principal, trip to lodge 'not authorised'

Lesufi suspends Parktown Boys' High principal, trip to lodge 'not authorised'

Gauteng Education MEC says officials from the department who handled the school's application for the camp are also suspended.

Ruling against EFF defends journalism from defamatory attacks - Anton Harber

Ruling against EFF defends journalism from defamatory attacks - Anton Harber

Wits University Caxton journalism professor and Thandeka Gqubule have won their defamation case against the EFF.

The 50th annual World Economic Forum is about to end. It’s been a weird one

The 50th annual World Economic Forum is about to end. It’s been a weird one

SA missing in action. Trump vs Thunberg. Stakeholder capitalism. A wrap of our coverage of this year’s World Economic Forum.