Mkhwebane heads to Supreme Court of Appeal over Estina report

The North Gauteng High Court has dismissed Public Protector Busisiswe Mkhwebane's application for leave to appeal the Estina Dairy Farm report ruling.

The application has been dismissed with costs.

In May, Judge Ronel Tolmay declared her report unlawful, unconstitutional and invalid.

Eyewitness News reporter Nthakoana Ngatane has more.

Judge Ronel Tolmay had said in May that Mkhwebane has turned a blind eye to the key complaints in the matter.

Nthakoana Ngatane, Reporter - Eyewitness News

She slapped her office with 85% of the costs and her personally with 7.5% of the legal costs. She was trying to appeal that order so she and her office don't pay those costs.

Nthakoana Ngatane, Reporter - Eyewitness News

Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution executive secretary Lawson Naidoo says they are not surprised by today's judgment.

It would come as no surprise if the Public Protector decides to lodge her own application and deal directly with the SCA.

Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution 

Listen to the full interview below...


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Mathematics syllabus is enormous to be covered within a year,' says expert

'Mathematics syllabus is enormous to be covered within a year,' says expert

Wits University mathematics lecturer Dr Jacques du Plessis says teachers are racing against time in the classroom.

Home Affairs gazettes new tougher laws for refugees and and asylum seekers

Home Affairs gazettes new tougher laws for refugees and and asylum seekers

Minister Aaron Motsoaledi says those who commit fraud face expulsion for destroying the sovereignty of the country.

Former Reserve Bank deputy governor Daniel Mminele appointed Absa CEO

Former Reserve Bank deputy governor Daniel Mminele appointed Absa CEO

Absa head of corporate communications Songezo Zibi says Mminele has pedigree both in terms of policy and commercial banking.

Eskom says system still constrained but load shedding unlikely for the week

Eskom says system still constrained but load shedding unlikely for the week

Spokesperson Dikatso Mothae confirms that CEO André de Ruyter has officially started work at the power utility.

Public Protector to challenge Estina Dairy Farm High Court ruling

Public Protector to challenge Estina Dairy Farm High Court ruling

Tiso Black Star's Karyn Maughan explains why the Busisiwe Mkhwebane has chosen to dispute Judge Ronel Tolmay's judgment.

Mkhwebane 'disappointed' over latest legal loss related to Estina report

Mkhwebane 'disappointed' over latest legal loss related to Estina report

The High Court has ordered that the Public Protector personally pay some of the legal costs for the DA and Casac.

Popular articles
Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight pleads for more donations to conduct cataract surgeries

Right to Sight trustee Dr Matt Young says they get donations at the most time but now need big sponsors.

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

Remains of Cato Manor 9 returned on anniversary of their hanging

The Cato Manor 9 were hanged in 1961 by the apartheid after taking part in an uprising on 24 January 1960.

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

Zakes Bantwini opens up about his latest single 'Amanga'

The musician says he never writes songs about his personal life but this latest single is too personal for him.

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa extends registration deadline in the wake of union protests

Unisa acting director of communications Lusani Netshitomboni says they encourage students to register online.

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Jacques Nienaber confirmed as new Springboks head coach

Mzwandile Stick has been reappointed as an assistant coach while in an innovative inclusion, Felix Jones will continue but in a new role as a European-based coaching consultant.

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Statistics show decline in mining fatalities

Department of Minerals and Energy chief inspector of mine David Msiza says more needs to be done.

Parliament Speaker says yes to motion to start proceedings to remove PP

Parliament Speaker says yes to motion to start proceedings to remove PP

The fresh calls for Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s removal come after Parliament adopted new rules for the removal of a Public Protector.

 Lesufi suspends Parktown Boys' High principal, trip to lodge 'not authorised'

Lesufi suspends Parktown Boys' High principal, trip to lodge 'not authorised'

Gauteng Education MEC says officials from the department who handled the school's application for the camp are also suspended.

Ruling against EFF defends journalism from defamatory attacks - Anton Harber

Ruling against EFF defends journalism from defamatory attacks - Anton Harber

Wits University Caxton journalism professor and Thandeka Gqubule have won their defamation case against the EFF.

The 50th annual World Economic Forum is about to end. It’s been a weird one

The 50th annual World Economic Forum is about to end. It’s been a weird one

SA missing in action. Trump vs Thunberg. Stakeholder capitalism. A wrap of our coverage of this year’s World Economic Forum.