Competition commission loses three cases in two months - is this good or bad?

Cases of price fixing or market division brought by the commission against cement companies, furniture removal truck companies and travel and tour companies, were all dismissed.

Are firms increasingly opposing cases brought against them by the commission?

Bruce Whitfield wants to know if the criminalisation of cartel conduct in 2016 is a partial explanation for this trend.

Companies can no longer say mea culpa I've been fixing prices, here's some cash for a fine.

People can be held liable.

Reputational damage and the risk of civil damages claims must be taken into account before a firm decides to apply for leniency or settle with the commission.

These are three cartel cases - cartels are the fundmental sin of price settling. The fact that the commission is prosecuting cartels is a good thing for consumers. but what I think these cases are showing is companies are increasingly opposing cases and not settling with the commission. I think partly the fact of the criminalisation of cartel conduct. Criminal and reputational issues flow from that.

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys

Firms are more cautious about settling, particularly since the granting of leniency by the commission does not automatically grant immunity from prosecution by the National Prosecuting Authority.

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys

Companies that stood up against the commission and been successful is useful. It develops precedent which can help companies like myself to help firms in future

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys
File picture: Competition Commission officials, presented findings on the Market Services Data Inquiry, December 2019. Picture: @CompComSA/Twitter

LIsten to the entire sound clip below.

Get the 10 most-read articles of the week from Bruce Whitfield’s The Money Show, emailed to you every Friday morning.

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
South Africa’s economy to shrink by 23.5% in 2Q/2020 – Absa forecast

South Africa’s economy to shrink by 23.5% in 2Q/2020 – Absa forecast

Africa’s most developed economy is heading for a very cold economic winter, says Absa Senior Economist Peter Worthington.

Covid-19: Struggling to pay - or collect - the rent?

Covid-19: Struggling to pay - or collect - the rent?

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews property lawyer Julian Scher about rental payment problems caused by Covid-19.

'If you still have a job, get rid of your debt as fast as you can'

'If you still have a job, get rid of your debt as fast as you can'

Personal finance expert Warren Ingram has advice on how to survive – or even thrive – amidst the Covid-19 outbreak.

[WATCH] How are babies made? This seven-year-old girl's theory goes viral

[WATCH] How are babies made? This seven-year-old girl's theory goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

R114m lotto winner has been found ... and she prioritises her kids' education

R114m lotto winner has been found ... and she prioritises her kids' education

Ithuba corporate relations executive Khensani Mabuza says the 35-year-old mother of four has been assigned a financial counsellor.

Train torching suspects released as police bungle case

Train torching suspects released as police bungle case

The National Prosecuting Authority says it had insufficient evidence hence the matter was not placed on the court roll.

Popular articles
[WATCH] Journalists soldier on updating the nation during lockdown

[WATCH] Journalists soldier on updating the nation during lockdown

Frontline heroes: Eyewitness News unpacks a working day in the lives of journalists during the lockdown.

COVID-19 claims two more lives and positive cases now sit at 1,505

COVID-19 claims two more lives and positive cases now sit at 1,505

Health Minsiter Zweli Mkhize briefed the nation from the Khayelitsha Hospital in the Western Cape on Friday afternoon.

Soul singer Bill Withers dies

Soul singer Bill Withers dies

According to a statement released by his family a short while ago, Withers died of heart complications.

 FF Plus founder Constand Viljoen dies at age 86

FF Plus founder Constand Viljoen dies at age 86

The former South African Defence Force commander died earlier on Friday due to what's been described as natural causes.

Ipid investigates after 8 deaths recorded since lockdown

Ipid investigates after 8 deaths recorded since lockdown

About a week into the national lockdown, the Ipid said it was working on 12 cases where officers have been implicated in wrongdoing during this period.

Premium spirits distributor pledges R2m to support bartenders and waiters

Premium spirits distributor pledges R2m to support bartenders and waiters

The initiative by Pernord Ricard South Africa will benefit at least 1,000 workers affected by the lockdown.

UJ makes use of 3D printing to make surgical face shields

UJ makes use of 3D printing to make surgical face shields

Library and Information Centre executive director professor Maria Frahm-Arp says the shield is reusable.

Construction company offers sanitisers and soaps to those in need

Construction company offers sanitisers and soaps to those in need

Hallfax CEO Femi Adeleke explains how the process of giving away the sanitisers work.

Lawyers for Human Rights want waste reclaimers to continue working

Lawyers for Human Rights want waste reclaimers to continue working

The organisation says it has sent a letter of demand to the City of Tshwane with no response.

Don't let FOMO get to you, join the baking club with these simple bread recipes

Don't let FOMO get to you, join the baking club with these simple bread recipes

Food critic Anna Trapido says baking can be quite soothing and people are looking for that.