Competition commission loses three cases in two months - is this good or bad?

Cases of price fixing or market division brought by the commission against cement companies, furniture removal truck companies and travel and tour companies, were all dismissed.

Are firms increasingly opposing cases brought against them by the commission?

Bruce Whitfield wants to know if the criminalisation of cartel conduct in 2016 is a partial explanation for this trend.

Companies can no longer say mea culpa I've been fixing prices, here's some cash for a fine.

People can be held liable.

Reputational damage and the risk of civil damages claims must be taken into account before a firm decides to apply for leniency or settle with the commission.

These are three cartel cases - cartels are the fundmental sin of price settling. The fact that the commission is prosecuting cartels is a good thing for consumers. but what I think these cases are showing is companies are increasingly opposing cases and not settling with the commission. I think partly the fact of the criminalisation of cartel conduct. Criminal and reputational issues flow from that.

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys

Firms are more cautious about settling, particularly since the granting of leniency by the commission does not automatically grant immunity from prosecution by the National Prosecuting Authority.

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys

Companies that stood up against the commission and been successful is useful. It develops precedent which can help companies like myself to help firms in future

Pieter Steyn, Werksmans Attorneys
File picture: Competition Commission officials, presented findings on the Market Services Data Inquiry, December 2019. Picture: @CompComSA/Twitter

LIsten to the entire sound clip below.

Get the 10 most-read articles of the week from Bruce Whitfield’s The Money Show, emailed to you every Friday morning.

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Curro explains profit loss and its strength in a slack economy

Curro explains profit loss and its strength in a slack economy

The private schooling business has always been seen as very resilient in the face of economic downturns.

How it works: Deep Fakes or deepfake video

How it works: Deep Fakes or deepfake video

Deepfake video is one of the scariest new technologies in the world of fake news.

Nando's reply to a mouldy burger - the best and the worst ads of the week

Nando's reply to a mouldy burger - the best and the worst ads of the week

A witty reply to a mouldy Whopper is a winner.

[WATCH] How are babies made? This seven-year-old girl's theory goes viral

[WATCH] How are babies made? This seven-year-old girl's theory goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.

R114m lotto winner has been found ... and she prioritises her kids' education

R114m lotto winner has been found ... and she prioritises her kids' education

Ithuba corporate relations executive Khensani Mabuza says the 35-year-old mother of four has been assigned a financial counsellor.

Train torching suspects released as police bungle case

Train torching suspects released as police bungle case

The National Prosecuting Authority says it had insufficient evidence hence the matter was not placed on the court roll.

Popular articles
 Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended over Bosasa allegations

Nair was charged with two counts of misconduct in November last year following a preliminary investigation by the ministry.

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

Literacy Project to empower caregivers of pre-school children

CEO Steven Roux says they identified that there is a significant number of children who are not getting access to good creches.

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

Frustrated judge tells Dudu Myeni to answer questions directly - report

The former SA chairperson was giving evidence in the delinquency case brought by Outa and the SA Pilots Association

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Economist Dr Sean Miller says Eskom is a national problem and it is going to need to be bailed out.

Budget 2020: Finance Minister Mboweni's full speech

Budget 2020: Finance Minister Mboweni's full speech

The documents that underpin Finance Minister Tito Mboweni's annual Budget Speech paint a picture of an economy in a serious crunch.

Mboweni announces R2 billion in personal tax relief

Mboweni announces R2 billion in personal tax relief

Relief for taxpayers will come through above-inflation increases in all tax brackets and will be welcome news, although excise duties on alcohol and tobacco go up along with a 25 cent a litre increase in fuel levies.

Sin taxes rise again, and now vapers will also have to pay more

Sin taxes rise again, and now vapers will also have to pay more

In his Budget Speech, Finance Minister has Tito Mboweni announced a new tax on vapers.

It is necessary for Minister Tito Mboweni to revise growth forecast - expert

It is necessary for Minister Tito Mboweni to revise growth forecast - expert

Pundits share their thoughts on what to expect from the budget speech by Finance Minister Tito Mboweni.

2020 BUDGET SPEECH: Cosatu urges government to deal with wastage

2020 BUDGET SPEECH: Cosatu urges government to deal with wastage

Finance Minister Tito Mboweni is set to address Parliament on Wednesday afternoon.

Missing Queens High School pupil found at Maponya Mall

Missing Queens High School pupil found at Maponya Mall

Gauteng Education Department spokesperson Steve Mabona and EWN reporter Mia Lindeque give details around the alleged kidnapping.