Budget appeased rating agencies but showdown looms with unions - Karima Brown

Finance Minister Tito Mboweni tabled his R1.95 trillion Budget in Parliament on Wednesday.

In an attempt to save billions of rand, Mboweni announced major cuts to salaries and benefits in the next three years in the public wage bill by 1%.

RELATED: Budget 2020: The good, the bad, and the ugly

He also announced no major tax increases, and instead gave taxpayers relief to the tune of R2 billion.

What are the practical implications for this budget?

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a discussion on Mboweni's budget with Investec chief economist Annabel Bishop, political analyst and broadcaster Karima Brown as well as Deloitte SA tax partner Kabelo Malapela.

RELATED: Unions not happy with Mboweni's announcement to cut public wage bill by 1%

I was fascinated by this budget from a political analysis point of view because I thought it incredibly braved some of the choices that the entire government had made, like deciding it was not compulsory to raise taxes and find other ways to stimulate the economy.

Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter

Malapela says she was surprised by the overall budget that Mboweni delivered.

Because generally, to deal with a deficit, raising taxes is the natural inclination. Everyone was expecting it and then the minister comes on and does nothing about corporate taxes and gives back to individuals. I was surprised, now you have not raised taxes but you are still in a deficit, how do you plug that hole?

Kabelo Malapela, Tax partner - Deloitte SA

Brown says her first takeaway from the speech was that it appeased the rating agencies but a showdown looms with unions.

For me, the African National Congress is betting on the black middle class to regain its position that it has lost in the polls. This is a very risky strategy.

Karima Brown, Political analyst and broadcaster

Bishop concurs with the others and says she was surprised by the budget.

It would have been silly to push up VAT but at the same time expect the civil servants to pay more VAT and use that money to give them salary increases.

Annabel Bishop, Chief economist - Investec

Listen below to the full analysis and reaction on Mboweni's budget speech:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Unions not happy with Mboweni's announcement to cut public wage bill by 1%

Unions not happy with Mboweni's announcement to cut public wage bill by 1%

Public Servants Association's Reuben Maleka says the government is trying to pit unions against the public.

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Mboweni allocates R60-billion for SAA and Eskom

Economist Dr Sean Miller says Eskom is a national problem and it is going to need to be bailed out.

Budget 2020: Finance Minister Mboweni's full speech

Budget 2020: Finance Minister Mboweni's full speech

The documents that underpin Finance Minister Tito Mboweni's annual Budget Speech paint a picture of an economy in a serious crunch.

Sin taxes rise again, and now vapers will also have to pay more

Sin taxes rise again, and now vapers will also have to pay more

In his Budget Speech, Finance Minister has Tito Mboweni announced a new tax on vapers.

Mboweni announces R2 billion in personal tax relief

Mboweni announces R2 billion in personal tax relief

Relief for taxpayers will come through above-inflation increases in all tax brackets and will be welcome news, although excise duties on alcohol and tobacco go up along with a 25 cent a litre increase in fuel levies.

It is necessary for Minister Tito Mboweni to revise growth forecast - expert

It is necessary for Minister Tito Mboweni to revise growth forecast - expert

Pundits share their thoughts on what to expect from the budget speech by Finance Minister Tito Mboweni.

Tito Mboweni increasing VAT is not politically palatable at moment - Economist

Tito Mboweni increasing VAT is not politically palatable at moment - Economist

Busisiwe Radebe looks at the different things that South Africans could hear from the finance minister's budget speech.

Tito Mboweni's fun dagga tweet - let's separate the wheat from the chaff

Tito Mboweni's fun dagga tweet - let's separate the wheat from the chaff

Tito Mboweni has sent out a fun tweet about "stuff" growing on his farm. How high should our hopes be for the dagga industry?

Popular articles
#Lockdown: How to assist family members who are addicts, especially alcoholics

#Lockdown: How to assist family members who are addicts, especially alcoholics

Substances disorder specialist Dr Duncan Laurenson shares what you can do if you are in lockdown with an addict.

Academics propose special COVID-19 grant for low-income earners and poor

Academics propose special COVID-19 grant for low-income earners and poor

Wits senior lecturer Lumkile Mondi is one of the academics and he explains exactly what it is they are calling for.

More than 20 cases of misconduct lodged with Ipid, military ombudsman so far

More than 20 cases of misconduct lodged with Ipid, military ombudsman so far

Ipid spokesperson Sontaga Seisa says their services are available and communities should report any form of misconduct.

New screening and testing initiative aimed at fighting COVID-19 underway

New screening and testing initiative aimed at fighting COVID-19 underway

Department of Health deputy director-general Dr Yogan Pillay says fieldworkers have been deployed to townships such as Alexandra.

KZN families rendered homeless despite moratorium on evictions -  Abahlali

KZN families rendered homeless despite moratorium on evictions - Abahlali

The Department of Justice has committed to looking into the matter.

Can we save the 2020 academic year? Minister Angie Motshekga believes we can

Can we save the 2020 academic year? Minister Angie Motshekga believes we can

The basic education minister says her department is working on a plan that will ensure that upcoming holidays are used for learning.

Gauteng Health Department suspends hospital visits

Gauteng Health Department suspends hospital visits

Only emergencies, surgical and medical outpatients as well as pregnant women and those collecting medication will be allowed.

Absa explains COVID-19 debt relief programme

Absa explains COVID-19 debt relief programme

Bank spokesperson Songezo Zibi says customers who have not received the SMS can call the bank directly.

OUTsurance commits R102 million to support COVID-19 efforts

OUTsurance commits R102 million to support COVID-19 efforts

OUTsurance is helping South Africa out in its greatest time of need.

 Backstreet Boys singing 'I want it that way' at different locations goes viral

Backstreet Boys singing 'I want it that way' at different locations goes viral

Khabazela shares some of the videos that went viral on Twitter and Facebook.