Why the law proposed to hold bar owners liable for drunks may not work

Liquor outlet owners may soon be held responsible for the behaviour of their inebriated patrons, even once they leave their premises.

With South Africa placing in the world’s top 5 when it comes to alcohol abuse, the Department of Trade and Industry has taken the debate to the public, starting with its proposed legislation.

(Also read our article: Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms)

CapeTalk presenter Kieno Kammies spoke with Leon Louw, Director of the Free Market Foundation about the flaws in the proposed legislation.

According Louw, the draft legislation has several impractical limitations.

The idea of vicarious liability exists in our law. Secondly, even the police are unable to conduct the precursor tests to assess intoxication. The law doesn't say that we may not serve liquor to drunk people. It holds owners liable if they serve them liquor and, thereafter, they to do something wrong.

Leon Louw, Director of the Free Market Foundation

The draft National Liquor Policy proposes that:

  • The availability of liquor be reduced by regulating days and hours when liquor sales will be permitted in accordance with the National Liquor Norms and Standards;

  • The national minimum legal age at which alcohol can be purchased and consumed be raised from 18 to twenty one 21 years;

  • Liquor premises be located at least 500 meters away from schools, places of worship; recreation facilities, rehabilitation or retreat centres, residential areas and public institutions;

  • The Minister of Trade and Industry determine the restrictions and parameters for advertising and marketing of liquor products. This includes the restriction of advertisement of the alcoholic beverages, prohibitions of sponsorship and promotion associated with alcoholic beverages;

The proposed legislation closes for public review on 13 August 2015.

For more information on how to comment on the National Liquor policy visit the Government website.

Listen to the full conversation from CapeTalk's Breakfast with Kieno Kammies:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

Former media exec molested 'hundreds' of boys and young men - Deon Wiggett

The final episode of Deon Wiggett's podcast series 'My Only Story' has been published in collaboration with News24.

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

District Six land claimants to discuss govt's proposed restitution plan

The District Six Reference Group will hold a meeting on Saturday to outline the proposals that the government has put on the table.

Is southern Africa drought drying up Victoria Falls?

Is southern Africa drought drying up Victoria Falls?

Harare-based BBC journalist Shingai Nyoka gives a first-hand account of the devastating effect of the drought on Zimbabwe.

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

'We're ready and able to deal with increased online payments on Black Friday'

PayFast MD Jonathan Smit says the spread of technologies available should help mitigate risk of compromising payment systems.

Why life sentences aren't the solution to SA's rape crisis

Why life sentences aren't the solution to SA's rape crisis

The criminal justice system needs to take action against the scourge of rape in SA, but longer prison sentences aren't the answer.

Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms

Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms

We explore the Department of Trade and Industry’s draft National Liquor Policy and outline its purpose with relevant stakeholders.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] Good Samaritans help bright refugee student cover fees shortfall

[LISTEN] Good Samaritans help bright refugee student cover fees shortfall

GroundUp first told the story of Triphin Mudzvengi who has been accepted to study civil engineering at Wits University.

South African couple stuck in China due to coronavirus outbreak

South African couple stuck in China due to coronavirus outbreak

Simone van Wyk says the couple is wearing masks even in the house and waiting patiently to come back home.

'The higher education system does not need to come to a state of pandemonium'

'The higher education system does not need to come to a state of pandemonium'

While SAUS has called for a national shutdown, it says practical commitments need to be made to clear historic debt.

Going down memory lane: 702's first tweet 10 years ago

Going down memory lane: 702's first tweet 10 years ago

We look at the station's social media activity over the decade. It started with 350 followers, today it is followed by 730,000.

Riverlea High School staff, pupils mourn for 3 teachers killed in crash

Riverlea High School staff, pupils mourn for 3 teachers killed in crash

The area where pupils usually play - which is a parking lot merged with a basketball court - is filled with colleagues, staff from other schools and community members who’ve come to offer their condolences.

Palestine rejects Trump's Middle East peace plan

Palestine rejects Trump's Middle East peace plan

Afro-Middle East Centre executive director Naeem Jeenah says the plan is one-sided & Palestine has been excluded from the process.

'Current approach to jobs is not working, a new approach is long overdue'

'Current approach to jobs is not working, a new approach is long overdue'

Centre for Development and Enterprise founder Anne Bernstein weighs in on her organisation's unemployment report.

'There is no obligation to afford the person a hearing at preliminary stage'

'There is no obligation to afford the person a hearing at preliminary stage'

Professor Pierre de Vos responds to the Public Protector's comments on a process looking to have her removed from her post.

Avail PIC funds to pay off Eskom debt - Cosatu

Avail PIC funds to pay off Eskom debt - Cosatu

Cosatu's spokesperson Sizwe Pamla says those who own the power utility must be forced to pay.

How prepared is SA if coronavirus hits our shores?

How prepared is SA if coronavirus hits our shores?

National Institute of Communicable Diseases medical epidemiologist Sibongile Walaza weighs in on the outbreak that has hit China.