What the NPA must prove to overturn the Oscar Pistorius conviction and sentence

Attorney David Dadic explores the basis for the success of the prosecution's appeal.

Appeals can only be made on rules of law not the facts of the case. The much discussed Dolus Eventualis requires the person to have a reasonable expectation for the outcome of the action. The principal argument is likely to be that firing specialised bullets into a confined space that he believed had a person in it would suggest he should have been able to see that firing four bullets would lead to death.

If that can be successfully appealed then the conviction changes from culpable homicide to murder, which changes the sentence from the current 5 years to a minimum of 15 years.

Take a listen to what is required for the State to succeed.


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
5300 health posts on offer not an election campaign device says Motsoaledi

5300 health posts on offer not an election campaign device says Motsoaledi

The health minister denies claims that the job announcements are an attempt to win over voters ahead of the 2019 elections.

Hawks nab seven traffic officials in Khayelitsha for taking bribes

Hawks nab seven traffic officials in Khayelitsha for taking bribes

Western Cape Hawks spokesperson says those who paid the bribes will also be arrested.

Live broadcasting of the Pistorius trial: a criminal law expert weighs in

Live broadcasting of the Pistorius trial: a criminal law expert weighs in

On the John Robbie Show, WITS Law's Prof. James Grant said of the media's involvement in the Pistorius trial: 'Journalists have been live-tweeting in court before this; a live broadcast was a natural next step.'

Masipa verdict on The State vs Oscar Pistorius - the ANCWL's take

Speaking outside the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria, ANCWL Gauteng spokesperson Jacqui Mofokeng said, 'We are very disappointed'.

'I think it should be murder'

Criminal attorney Tyrone Maseko's take before Masipa ruling

The #ConsideredView with @StephenGrootes: The NPA debacle

Stephen sheds light on the recent activity with the National Prosecuting Authority and queries why the leaders of the organisation are fighting again.

Popular articles
Former school patrol guard acquitted of all sexual abuse charges

Former school patrol guard acquitted of all sexual abuse charges

Johannes Molefe was accused of abusing dozens of children from the AB Xuma Primary School in Soweto last year.

Pop-up bar creates awareness around drunk driving

Pop-up bar creates awareness around drunk driving

Aware.org took on a bold campaign that has made South Africans pay attention.

Mabe faces ANC grievance panel over sexual harassment allegations on Wednesday

Mabe faces ANC grievance panel over sexual harassment allegations on Wednesday

EWN's Clement Manyathela says Pule Mabe is facing a grievance panel to answer to sexual harassment allegations against him.

Popular shoe brand Vans ask Ackermans to remove "knock-offs" from shelves

Popular shoe brand Vans ask Ackermans to remove "knock-offs" from shelves

Vans' brand manager says although this is a recurring problem its main concern is that this particular "fake" is a very close copy.

 'Having a senior official call Lindiwe Sisulu a prostitute is undiplomatic'

'Having a senior official call Lindiwe Sisulu a prostitute is undiplomatic'

Mail & Guardian Africa editor Simon Allison says its undiplomatic for a Rwandan official to call Sisulu names.

[Watch the latest adverts] Do you agree? Chicken Licken is the boss of Nando’s!

[Watch the latest adverts] Do you agree? Chicken Licken is the boss of Nando’s!

Chicken Licken’s latest ad flame-grills the most recent one by Nando’s, says Nicholas Kühne of Wunderbrand.

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

Ray White interviews Pauli van Wyk, an investigative journalist with Scorpio at Daily Maverick.