State Capture Inquiry

How Sars and the State got captured (by Pauli Van Wyk, Daily Maverick)

FILE: Tom Moyane. Picture: Kayleen Morgan/EWN

(Also read: 'Increased taxes among the longer-term effects of Moyane’s dismantling of Sars')

By any lawful measure or standard, my tenure at Sars was the most successful in the democratic era.

Tom Moyane

Why then was he removed?

Moyane says it’s because of a vast conspiracy against him by President Cyril Ramaphosa, Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan and “the media”.

His Trumpian statement follows on previous legal attempts by him to evade the inquiry into Sars under him as well as his disciplinary hearing, both of which are happening at the same time.

Some of the other reality-twisting claims Moyane has made in his Constitutional Court challenge of his disciplinary hearing and the Sars Inquiry:

  • The tax collection shortfall last year totals R50 billion, a figure excepted as true by everyone, except Moyane.

  • Moyane did nothing wrong in handling the fortune deposited into Jonas Makwakwa's accounts, despite a Financial Intelligence Centre report.

  • The millions the Guptas received in VAT refunds were also not his fault - other employees are to blame.

  • Moyane defended Bain & Company’s “restructuring” of Sars, despite the company admitting wrongdoing and agreeing to pay back the R164 million it earned for the work.

  • He commended the Sunday Times for "reporting courageously" on the (we now know non-existent) “rogue unit” at Sars, even though the Sunday Times has itself admitted its error and apologised.

Ray White (in for Bruce Whitfield on The Money Show) asked Pauli Van Wyk, an investigative journalist with Scorpio at Daily Maverick, to explain how Sars and the State got captured.

Listen to the interview in the audio below (and/or scroll down for quotes from it).

We’re making a mistake if we think it’s one family… there are many… we can look at the cigarette barons… there are many. This happens when you have a weak state and a weak leader.

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

It’s a process of networking… of enforcing that network… by using the name of your top boogie man… The whole Gutpa-network was very layered… They would have Mr Zuma and beyond that, they would have the top of an institution… they would have certain people in key places…

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

Someone who assisted Mr Zuma with his tax affairs told me… He has two fears. The one is being poor and the second is being in jail again.

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

Mr Zuma had tax problems… They struggled to get him tax compliant… It was also his wives, children and friends…

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

It didn’t start with Mr Zuma… If we look at Thabo Mbeki and how he used the Scorpions…

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

I found things that contradicted the Sunday Times… the more I probed the more it contradicted them… I tried to prove them right and to this day I couldn’t… The women have been ousted, but the men are still working.

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

It’s no coincidence that Mr Zuma was removed from his position and the underworld is starting to challenge each other.

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

The heart-breaking part for me was seeing how people cried before a commission… the hurt, injury and trauma… how this Government treated people being good to this country!

Pauli van Wyk, Scorpio at Daily Maverick

Enjoy The Money Show, but miss it sometimes?

Get the best bits emailed to you daily, right after it ends:

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Vytjie Mentor pressed on discrepancies in her testimony

Vytjie Mentor pressed on discrepancies in her testimony

State capture inquiry says it hasn't found any evidence of the SAA flight where she apparently met the Guptas for a Cabinet job.

Vytjie Mentor's testimony on meeting Atul Gupta doesn't add up, commission finds

Vytjie Mentor's testimony on meeting Atul Gupta doesn't add up, commission finds

Despite contradictory evidence presented at the state capture inquiry, Mentor has stuck to her guns on meeting Atul Gupta in China.

'Agrizzi's arrest could delay the work of the commission of inquiry'

'Agrizzi's arrest could delay the work of the commission of inquiry'

Journalist Karyn Maughn says Agrizzi's arrest could possibly hinder prospects of uncovering more corruption by the commission.

SIU boss welcomes Bosasa arrests and says expect more arrests to follow

SIU boss welcomes Bosasa arrests and says expect more arrests to follow

Head of the SIU Advocate Andy Mothibi says he hopes that these arrests will lead to guilty verdicts and convictions.

Hawks arrests Bosasa heavyweights. Is this the start of a wave of prosecutions?

Hawks arrests Bosasa heavyweights. Is this the start of a wave of prosecutions?

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Steven Powell (Director in Forensics at ENS Africa).

Bosasa arrests just the beginning, says Adriaan Basson

Bosasa arrests just the beginning, says Adriaan Basson

He says the SIU reported on Bosasa corruption in 2009, but nothing was done by the NPA or the then Correctional Services minister.

Popular articles
[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

[WATCH] Refentse Morake continues breaking cultural barriers through his music

The singer who says he's 'on the border of being Afrikaans and being African' joined Azania Mosaka for this week's #702Unplugged.

What happens to our bodies if we cut out sugar

What happens to our bodies if we cut out sugar

Naked Scientist Chris Smith explains.

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Why did Jussie Smollet fake his own attack? Eusebius and listeners weigh in

Eusebius McKaiser facilitates a debate on whether or not American actor Jussie Smollet faked his own attack.

[WATCH] SANDF members hilariously mess up a supposedly easy practice run

[WATCH] SANDF members hilariously mess up a supposedly easy practice run

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

[LISTEN] Wife of Vele Investments' Madzonga flatly denies VBS involvement

[LISTEN] Wife of Vele Investments' Madzonga flatly denies VBS involvement

Vele Investments CEO Robert Madzonga's estranged wife Khosi shares her side of the story on the VBS saga.

‘We’d be crazy to copy! Sometimes we get it wrong. There's no culture problem'

‘We’d be crazy to copy! Sometimes we get it wrong. There's no culture problem'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Ian Moir, CEO at Woolworths.

Is EOH corrupt? Is that why Microsoft ran for the hills? Its CEO explains…

Is EOH corrupt? Is that why Microsoft ran for the hills? Its CEO explains…

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Stephen van Coller, CEO at EOH Holdings.

'R23 million for rent a month seems huge. I don't think we could've done better'

'R23 million for rent a month seems huge. I don't think we could've done better'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Adrian Gore, founder and Group Chief Executive Officer at Discovery Limited.