State Capture Inquiry

Eusebius says Manyi will never be able to defend TNA as a bonifide newspaper

Former GCIS Head Mzwanele Manyi on Monday struggled to explain why under his tenure at the GCIS the then Gupta-owned The New Age received more government revenue than most daily newspapers.

He told the state capture inquiry that the newspaper received 4.5% of government spending but things got heated when he was asked about how much TNA received in its first year.

Show Host Eusebius McKaiser says Manyi dug a hole but instead of pushing the lawyer into it, he jumped into the hole himself.

READ: Manyi has made unusual requests during state capture testimony

It was interesting because Advocate Maleka, I thought if you are a law student you would have received a very good structural lesson of how to cross-examine without shouting, raising your tone and using too many words, in just asking simple questions and letting the dude on the stand speak as much as possible and eventually if you let someone speak, they reveal who they are.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

Mzwanele Manyi is like the clever person Hlaudi Motsoeneng. He is dodgy weird, the logic is circuitous, all of the above, maybe some of the above. But every now and then you think this guy is making sense.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

And then you let him speak long enough and suddenly he unravels. An example of this is that at one point he tells us that Telma is objective and it is the system that it was used to justify the disproportionate amounts of GCIS funding going to The New Age.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

So you say ok, we know you are lying but let us go with it, I kept thinking as I am eating my popcorn at home, can someone whisper the correct follow up question into Advocate Maleka's ear.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

And eventually, patiently he just says to him, can we talk about TNA and the audited figures in terms of circulation and readership, there were none were they?

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

And then you have a 180-degree turnaround from Mzwanele Manyi. Because suddenly he had to concede that even if Telma was the basis on which most established newspapers were getting less than a R100 000 a year, and TNA were getting upwards of a couple of million rands in its first year of business, that actually even the criteria that go into this particular template for deciding how to increase the spoils when it comes to government advertising, TNA couldn't have met the criteria.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

Eusebius adds that this is because we don't even know who read that paper.

And then what does he say at this point? He says, oh no, who cares about Telma as it is not objective. So 30 minutes ago, that was the objective basis on which you were giving disproportionate amounts of money to The New Age and now suddenly when you have been shown up, you say that is not the reason why so much money was put there.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

Here is the bottom line. There is no way in hell even with your linguistic austerity, you will never be able to defend The New Age as being a bonafide newspaper and not simply being a conduit for corruption.

Eusebius McKaiser, Show Host

Watch below and hear what Eusebius McKaiser had to say:

Listen below to the full comment and open line:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Manyi has made unusual requests during state capture testimony

Manyi has made unusual requests during state capture testimony

Clement Manyathela says Mzwanele Manyi has asked to show slides on a screen during his testimony.

EFF 'deliberately feeding the public with disinformation.' - Ferial Haffajee

EFF 'deliberately feeding the public with disinformation.' - Ferial Haffajee

Haffajee was named by Julius Malema as being part of a group of journalists he called the 'Ramaphosa Defence Force'.

'Were the ANC top-6 part of the decision to fire Nhlanhla Nene?'

'Were the ANC top-6 part of the decision to fire Nhlanhla Nene?'

Ray White (on The Money Show) interviews EWN Editor-In-Chief Mahlatse Mahlase.

 Nene takes the stand at the Zondo Commission, EFF says he must come clean

Nene takes the stand at the Zondo Commission, EFF says he must come clean

Casac Executive Secretary Lawson Naidoo says there isn't any real evidence behind the EFF's allegations at the moment.

How Sars and the State got captured (by Pauli Van Wyk, Daily Maverick)

How Sars and the State got captured (by Pauli Van Wyk, Daily Maverick)

Ray White (on The Money Show) interviews Pauli Van Wyk, an investigative journalist with Scorpio at Daily Maverick.

The country owes whistleblowers a huge debt for #Guptaleaks

The country owes whistleblowers a huge debt for #Guptaleaks

Two whistleblowers known as Stan and John lifted the hard drives containing the Gupta leaks.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] Court to rule if state should continue paying Zuma’s legal fees

[LISTEN] Court to rule if state should continue paying Zuma’s legal fees

Former president Jacob Zuma will hear on Thursday whether he will have to foot the bill for his corruption case.

How RMB went from 'too poor to buy a photocopier' to the largest bank in SA

How RMB went from 'too poor to buy a photocopier' to the largest bank in SA

Bruce Whitfield sat down with GT Ferreira, Laurie Dippenaar and Paul Harris, the inspirational founders of Rand Merchant Bank.

Pop-up bar creates awareness around drunk driving

Pop-up bar creates awareness around drunk driving

Aware.org took on a bold campaign that has made South Africans pay attention.

Popular shoe brand Vans ask Ackermans to remove "knock-offs" from shelves

Popular shoe brand Vans ask Ackermans to remove "knock-offs" from shelves

Vans' brand manager says although this is a recurring problem its main concern is that this particular "fake" is a very close copy.

 'Having a senior official call Lindiwe Sisulu a prostitute is undiplomatic'

'Having a senior official call Lindiwe Sisulu a prostitute is undiplomatic'

Mail & Guardian Africa editor Simon Allison says its undiplomatic for a Rwandan official to call Sisulu names.

[Watch the latest adverts] Do you agree? Chicken Licken is the boss of Nando’s!

[Watch the latest adverts] Do you agree? Chicken Licken is the boss of Nando’s!

Chicken Licken’s latest ad flame-grills the most recent one by Nando’s, says Nicholas Kühne of Wunderbrand.

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

'Evidence is solid. Poor people’s money was used illegally. Shivambu benefitted'

Ray White interviews Pauli van Wyk, an investigative journalist with Scorpio at Daily Maverick.