The Science Of ...

Unsure where you stand on NHI? Experts slug it out in an emotional debate…

Doctor (pixabay.com, 2019)

We don’t say private security must be banned… This is mumbo-jumbo… it’s all garbage. The reality is we deal with a state that is not capable… We need policies that make sense in our reality…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

We had a terrible nine years… we need to start charting a path to shared prosperity… access to health can do that…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

(Also, read: 'NHI dropped on us like a dog dropping a huge, stinking turd in your kitchen!')

Government is working on a National Health Insurance (NHI) system for South Africa.

NHI aims to provide equal access to healthcare for all South Africans.

Philosophically, many South Africans seem to support NHI but fear it’s unworkable and poses an existential threat to the well-functioning private healthcare system.

There’s also the threat of corruption.

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield hosted a debate on NHI.

He asked Paul Theron (MD at Vestact Asset Management) and Russell Rensburg (Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy at University of the Witwatersrand) to slug it out.

Listen to the debate in the audio below (and scroll down for more quotes from it).

We need to de-commodify health…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

There’s a big trust deficit…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

It’s not going to pass Constitutional muster… Russel, you realise this thing is going to fail?

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

I fail to see why wealthier individuals… should be prevented… you’re going to ruin healthcare…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

70% of our specialists work in the private sector… It’s probably the state’s fault…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

If you want public health services to improve, run it better… The provinces that don’t work are those that are run by corrupt ANC administrations… A collapsing state system that is trying to cover up its faults…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

You get a much better level of private care in this country than you get from the NHS in the UK.

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

This thing could have a fantastic upside for hospital groups…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

We’re taking a bit of a gamble here…

Russell Rensburg, Programme Manager Health Systems and Policy - University of the Witwatersrand

If the government is serious… they would turn it over to the private sector… Wasting money… rank corruption… but somehow, we think it’s a clever idea…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

The government doesn't have any more money… This thing is going to fail…

Paul Theron, MD - Vestact Asset Management

Enjoy The Money Show, but miss it sometimes?

Get the best bits emailed to you daily, right after it ends:

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
How Stellenbosch became a breeding ground for Afrikaner billionaire businessmen

How Stellenbosch became a breeding ground for Afrikaner billionaire businessmen

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews Pieter du Toit, author of "The Stellenbosch Mafia: Inside the Billionaires' Club".

This fund (SA SME Fund) worth R1.2 billion wants to help black businesses grow

This fund (SA SME Fund) worth R1.2 billion wants to help black businesses grow

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Ketso Gordhan, CEO at SA SME Fund.

Happy 100th birthday, Landbouweekblad!

Happy 100th birthday, Landbouweekblad!

Bruce Whitfield interviews Chris Burgess, Editor-in-chief at Landbouweekblad, South Africa’s legendary magazine about farming.

The story of Marcel’s 'better than sex' frozen yoghurt

The story of Marcel’s 'better than sex' frozen yoghurt

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nicole Westwig, Managing Director at Marcel's.

How to stop them from stealing your idea (by Ubuntu Baba's lawyer)

How to stop them from stealing your idea (by Ubuntu Baba's lawyer)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Andrew Papadopoulos, Trade Mark Attorney at KISCH IP.

How to quit your job so you can follow your dream

How to quit your job so you can follow your dream

Ever dreamt of just doing it? You may want a few pointers from someone who did. Meet Callan Williamson of Tortilla Modern Mexican.

Popular articles
In the new world of virtual meetings and interviews, what are the ground rules?

In the new world of virtual meetings and interviews, what are the ground rules?

World Wide Worx MD Arthur Goldstuck gives tips on what to do during an interview on Skype or something similar.

SARB warns that the economy may shrink by up to 4% due to coronavirus

SARB warns that the economy may shrink by up to 4% due to coronavirus

George Glynos, head of research at ETM Analytics,

Matric revision podcast by Gauteng Education Department --- working with 702

Matric revision podcast by Gauteng Education Department --- working with 702

Pupils are able to access the podcast lessons at anytime that is suitable for them in the comfort of their homes.

Include persons living with disabilities in fight against COVID-19 - ministry

Include persons living with disabilities in fight against COVID-19 - ministry

Deputy Minister Hlengiwe Mkhize spoke about how containment measures can be isolating for those who rely on the support of others.

TV personality Vinolia 'V-Mash' Mashego passes away

TV personality Vinolia 'V-Mash' Mashego passes away

The family says the former Jam Alley presenter passed away in her sleep.

Grandmother of killed Soweto girl pleads with community to volunteer info

Grandmother of killed Soweto girl pleads with community to volunteer info

EWN reporter Mia Lindeque says the grandmother says if there wasn't a lockdown people would have stopped the culprits.

Company pledges 20,000 face shields in fight against COVID-19

Company pledges 20,000 face shields in fight against COVID-19

Dispak Group has pledged 10,000 face shields to the Gauteng Health Department and another 10,000 to healthcare workers.

[LISTEN] Research into 'Life after COVID-19'

[LISTEN] Research into 'Life after COVID-19'

Flux Trend future finance specialist and trend translator Bronwyn Williams gives details into what the research will focus on.

'Experts think we could possibly see first sign of a vaccine in about a year'

'Experts think we could possibly see first sign of a vaccine in about a year'

Africa Check's acting deputy editor Kate Wilkinson unpacks claims surrounding COVID-19.

Online South Africans give government a nod on COVID-19

Online South Africans give government a nod on COVID-19

Ipsos public affairs director Mari Harris says 61% of online South Africans say they have confidence in the response to coronavirus.