Streaming issues? Report here
Joanne Joseph 702 Gradients Joanne Joseph 702 Gradients
Afternoon Drive with Joanne Joseph
15:00 - 18:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
See full line-up
Afternoon Drive with Joanne Joseph
15:00 - 18:00
Home
arrow_forward
Opinion
fiber_manual_record
Business

Debating a wealth tax: 'It raises a moral question in SA's unequal society'

3 May 2020 12:02 PM
Tags:
Poverty and inequality
SA inequality
Wealth tax
Judge Dennis Davis
COVID-19
Southern Centre for Inequality Studies

Judge Dennis Davis (Davis Tax Committee) weighs in on a study which finds 3,500 individuals own 15% of South Africa's wealth.

"The consequences of the COVID-19 lockdown are yet to be fully determined and understood. But one thing we can be fairly certain of – in South Africa its impact will be shaped by the country’s inequalities."

That's the introduction to an article published on theconversation.com arguing for why South Africa needs a wealth tax, right now.

The authors summarise their study (Southern Centre for Inequality Studies at Wits University) which shows that 3,500 individuals own 15% of the country's wealth. They propose the introduction of a progressive solidarity wealth tax.

Alexandra township residents gesture and chant slogans as they clash with the Johannesburg Metro Police on 3 April 2019 in Johannesburg, South Africa during a total shutdown of the township due to a protest against the lack of service delivery. Picture: AFP

Africa Melane gets input from Judge Dennis Davis, chairperson of the Davis Tax Committee.

While he disagrees with the figure posited in the article for income from a wealth tax, Davis does strongly believe in the concept of the tax in a society known as the most unequal in the world.

I think Covid-19 has shown just exactly what a dreadful mess we're in because of, well, 300 years but certainly even wasted years recently when inequality has not in fact not got better.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Davis says this state of affairs raises a fundamental moral question:

Shouldn't people who really have immense amounts of wealth - and they're a very small percentage - be paying more to the national effort in order to reconstruct our society? Any decent person thinking about it should think very seriously about why we shouldn't have a wealth tax.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Some callers questioned why, if taxes were paid by a generation, these people should still pay more?

Well, they're certainly paying income tax, that is true and they do pay VAT but everybody pays VAT. It is also true that more recently we've had a capital gains tax, but that hasn't been there forever... and you've got concessional taxes on dividends.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Unrealised wealth is not taxed as opposed to income and it's unconscionable it seems to me that if you look at the statistics in a country like South Africa, number one lots of people are not paying that kind of tax. Let me give you an example: There seem to be only 6,000 people in the country who report income of more than R5-million.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Now I challenge you just to take a drive when Covid-19 is over around Bishops Court, Constantia, Sandton, Bryanston, etcetera, and look at all those large homes. Seriously ask yourself: Have we got only 6,000 people who report taxable income of more than R5-million? I seriously doubt it.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

I think a whole lot of people, through accretion of capital that is not realised, that does not pay tax on that or pays it very late in the day, has estate duty that is very light and therefore there's huge transfer of wealth to the next generation that didn't earn it in the first place - all of that surely counts in circumstances in a country as unequal as ours.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Davis concludes that surely we owe those people who essentially have suffered under 300 years of racist rule and those who came after, an obligation to reconstruct South African society.

If we've got more than they have, then we jolly well should make that contribution... We must have that debate because that's the debate that actually makes us into a nation of 60-million people, not a nation divided into those of us who are wealthy and those of us who are poor.

Judge Dennis Davis, Chair - Davis Tax Committee

Listen to the thought-provoking conversation on Weekend Breakfast with Africa Melane:


This article first appeared on CapeTalk : Debating a wealth tax: 'It raises a moral question in SA's unequal society'


3 May 2020 12:02 PM
Tags:
Poverty and inequality
SA inequality
Wealth tax
Judge Dennis Davis
COVID-19
Southern Centre for Inequality Studies

Recommended

More from Opinion

Maize field mealie farm farmer agriculture 123rf 123rfbusiness 123rflifestyle

Covid-19 makes it clear – African agriculture is vital, now more than ever

14 July 2020 2:23 PM

The economy is shedding jobs – but not in agriculture, says Roux Wildenboer, Head of Agriculture at Absa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

160520DineoMoeketsi.jpg

'I spend extravagantly on shoes. I have various pairs of Christian Louboutin'

13 July 2020 8:15 PM

Arabile Gumede interviews actress Dineo Moeketsi (Langa) about her attitude to money and beliefs about it.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

foschinijpg

Foschini offers to buy Jet from Edcon

13 July 2020 7:34 PM

The Foschini Group is offering to buy 371 JET stores. The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews portfolio manager Evan Walker.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Quantitative easing printing money 123rfbusiness 123rf

Why South Africa – much like Zimbabwe - can’t print money to pay for Covid-19

13 July 2020 7:10 PM

Why "quantitative easing" can’t work in South Africa, according to Nazmeera Moola (Head of SA Investments at Ninety One).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Red wine white woman female funny reaction 123rf 123rflifestyle

'Few restaurants will now survive without selling alcohol. We were blindsided'

13 July 2020 6:33 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews reps from the Restaurant Association Of SA, Business Unity SA and the National Liquor Traders Council.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

180831-old-mutual-edjpg

Old Mutual's hackneyed new TV ad looks like Allan Gray in green – Andy Rice

7 July 2020 7:38 PM

Ouch! The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield asks Andy Rice why he gives Old Mutual’s new television commercial a “zero”.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Clover blue man

Clover’s trippy blue bottle ad campaign – so bad (and bizarre) it’s good

7 July 2020 7:30 PM

People will be talking about it ‘till they’re blue in the face. The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews ad expert Andy Rice.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Covid-19 insurance 123rf 123rfbusiness 123rflifestyle 123rfpersonalfinance

Shareholder activists grill Santam about 'business interruption insurance'

7 July 2020 6:47 PM

The lockdown did it – not the pandemic – so we can’t pay, argues Santam. Bruce Whitfield interviews Tracey Davies of Just Share.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Aisha Pandor SweepSouth Alen Ribic

Job won’t make you rich. You must earn in your sleep - Aisha Pandor, SweepSouth

6 July 2020 8:39 PM

Bruce Whitfield talks to SweepSouth cofounder Aisha Pandor about her attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Frog in a pot

Are we boiling frogs? And why do SUV drivers look so confused, asks Tom Eaton

6 July 2020 8:18 PM

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews columnist Tom Eaton about his new book, "Is it me, or is it getting hot in here?"

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Business

Maize field mealie farm farmer agriculture 123rf 123rfbusiness 123rflifestyle

Covid-19 makes it clear – African agriculture is vital, now more than ever

14 July 2020 2:23 PM

The economy is shedding jobs – but not in agriculture, says Roux Wildenboer, Head of Agriculture at Absa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

160520DineoMoeketsi.jpg

'I spend extravagantly on shoes. I have various pairs of Christian Louboutin'

13 July 2020 8:15 PM

Arabile Gumede interviews actress Dineo Moeketsi (Langa) about her attitude to money and beliefs about it.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

foschinijpg

Foschini offers to buy Jet from Edcon

13 July 2020 7:34 PM

The Foschini Group is offering to buy 371 JET stores. The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews portfolio manager Evan Walker.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Quantitative easing printing money 123rfbusiness 123rf

Why South Africa – much like Zimbabwe - can’t print money to pay for Covid-19

13 July 2020 7:10 PM

Why "quantitative easing" can’t work in South Africa, according to Nazmeera Moola (Head of SA Investments at Ninety One).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Red wine white woman female funny reaction 123rf 123rflifestyle

'Few restaurants will now survive without selling alcohol. We were blindsided'

13 July 2020 6:33 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews reps from the Restaurant Association Of SA, Business Unity SA and the National Liquor Traders Council.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

ramaphosa-imbizojpg

Liquor trade council writes to Ramaphosa to ensure sale of liquor continues

12 July 2020 5:13 PM

Concerns have been raised over the impact of booze on trauma admissions since the ban on sales was lifted in June.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Restaurant with spaced table for Covid-19 social distancing

Load shedding yet another blow for struggling SA businesses

11 July 2020 2:19 PM

Eskom is implementing stage two load shedding for a second day, while technicians work to bring generating units back online.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Darkness, no electricity, load shedding

Loadshedding to be implemented from Friday - Eskom COO

10 July 2020 11:03 AM

More generating units have broken down, resulting in the utility battling to meet the high demand for electricity.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

wifi-internet-data-broadband-cell-phone-mobile-device-network-providers-123rf

Small Business Focus: How to get your marketing right in a shrinking media world

9 July 2020 8:38 PM

Pavlo Phitidis says focus must be on the customer group you are trying to reach. You've got to get your demographics right.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

broken-heart-broke-money-coins-finances-love-relationship-divorce-break-up-123rf

Personal Finance Feature: Julia - The super saver

9 July 2020 8:02 PM

Though leaving corporate to venture into tourism has been a big test of resilience, she is still happy with her decision.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward