Lockdown regulations for levels 3 & 4 declared invalid and unconstitutional
JOHANNESBURG - The Pretoria High Court has declared the regulations promulgated for COVID-19 lockdown levels four and three as unconstitutional and invalid.
Reyno Dawid de Beer and Liberty Fighters Network challenged the regulations as set by Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, arguing that they encroached on and limited their rights as contained in the Bill of Rights in the Constitution.
The court found that the lockdown regulations indeed did not satisfy the rationality test and were not justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom as contemplated in Section 36 of the Constitution.
The judgment however changes nothing for now.
#BREAKING The High Court has ruled that the lock down regulations of alert levels four and three - are invalid and unconstitutional.— EWN Reporter (@ewnreporter) June 2, 2020
#BREAKING The High Court has directed the Minister of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs, in consultation with the relevant ministers - to review, amend and republish the regulations.— EWN Reporter (@ewnreporter) June 2, 2020
The declaration of invalidity on the rules is suspended until the minister reviews, amends and republishes the regulations in consultation with Cabinet.
The COVID-19 lockdown alert level three remains applicable.
"Declaration of invalidity is suspended until such time as the minister, after consultation with the cabinet, reviews, amends and republishes the regulations mentioned above with due consideration to the limitation each regulation has on the rights guaranteed in the bill of rights as contained in the constitution," read the ruling.
Although the applicants challenged several regulations, no arguments were made for the relaxation of laws regarding the blanket ban on the sale of tobacco products.
Judge Norman Davis has instead not ruled on the matter, saying that other courts would be dealing with it in the future.
These include challenges by the Fair-Trade Independent Tobacco Association, British American Tobacco and the Democratic Alliance (DA) among others.
Davis said that while Dlamini-Zuma’s declaration of a national state of disaster in terms of Section 27 of the Disaster Management Act in response to the COVID-19 pandemic was found to be rational, the regulations that followed were in a "substantial number of instances not rationally connected to the objectives of slowing the rate of infection or limiting the spread thereof".
Davis made several examples of such irrational decisions in the judgment, referring the limitations of exercise hours under level four and the total ban of night vigils ahead of funerals.
The minister has 14 days to comply with the court order, while she has also been ordered to pay for the costs of the first and second applicants.
READ: High Court ruling on lockdown regulations challenge
This article first appeared on EWN : Lockdown regulations for levels 3 & 4 declared invalid and unconstitutional
There were 111 new COVID-19 deaths: 50 from Gauteng; 35 from the Western Cape; 17 from Limpopo and 9 from the Eastern Cape.Read More
Joanne Joseph spoke to Cipla South Africa CEO Paul Miller to find out more.Read More
The Save Our SABC Coalition says the public broadcaster must look at other measures before retrenching staff.Read More
Solidarity union says a lack of communication from the Department of Social Development forced it to take this matter to court.Read More
Philip Truter was granted R50,000 bail in the Palm Ridge Commercial Crimes Court earlier on Monday, after saying he was unemployed and could not get a job.Read More
Veteran actress Lillian Dube says Mary Twala was professional, down to earth and respected people - young and old - the same way.Read More
The ANC said Mashatile will isolate for 14 days so his health can be monitored.Read More
He and his mutual bank co-accused face charges including racketeering, theft, fraud and corruption.Read More
Wits University emeritus professor of critical care Guy Richards says SA is running into a crisis as the virus peak approaches.Read More
Health Minister Zweli Mkhize said that the national coronavirus command council would evaluate whether Gauteng needed to go back to a hard lockdown.Read More