Windhoek beer ad banned in SA for entrenching 'toxic masculinity'
"Real men drink real beer. It's one of the great advertising stereotypes, isn't it?"
The stereotype of masculinity in advertising is under the spotlight again.
South Africa's Advertising Regulatory Board (ARB) has ruled that Windhoek Beer must withdraw or amend its TV campaign.

The advert features what the ARB describes as "a gentle looking, redheaded man" requesting a slice of lime with his Windhoek Lager.
The role of the man who consequently teases him is played by Scottish actor Gerard Butler who "is associated with macho movie roles".
The advertisement, rather than drawing attention to the purity of the taste of their product, paints a clear picture of an aspect of the target market; and that market is a stereotyped macho man who buckles to the pressure of his peers in order to fit in. This breaches the provisions of Clause 3.5 of Section II as read with the definitions.
Advertising Regulatory Board ruling
Branding and advertising expert Andy Rice weighs in on The Money Show.
He notes that this stereotype also features in earlier Windhoek commercials.
Remember another famous actor (Louis Gossett Jnr) monitoring a guy eyeing a red speedo and a pink drink?
I wonder whether it's harmless fun or whether there's something actually quite nasty at play here...
Bruce Whitfield, The Money Show host
The question is: Do advertising agencies and do their clients have a responsibility to lead society, or to reflect changes in society?
Andy Rice, Branding and advertising expert
I don't think that either of them is the wrong strategy, but the interesting thing is you can't really do both.
Andy Rice, Branding and advertising expert
The scale of judgment as to whether something is offensive or not is not absolute... Ads will fall at different levels on that spectrum according to who's viewing them.
Andy Rice, Branding and advertising expert
Watch the offending ad below:
Listen to the conversation on The Money Show:
More from Business

Always wanted to own a piece of a wine farm? Here's how to make it a reality
Hemelzicht Vineyards, a new investment model that gives the public the opportunity to own a share in a luxury wine estate.
Read More
Sea Harvest buoyant with 17% annual profit hike despite choppy economic seas
Despite lockdowns and the global pandemic the fish supplier stayed afloat and was even able to do swimmingly during the past year.
Read More
Public sector trade unions demand CPI plus 4% as final wage demand submitted
The demands have been submitted to the general secretary of the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC).
Read More
'State-sponsored corruption should outrage South Africans' - Sars commissioner
'I'm infuriated!' Commissioner Edward Kieswetter says he feels the need to speak truth to power. Strong words on The Money Show.
Read More
As export sales boost profit, Distell (Savanna, Klippies) eyes Africa expansion
Despite the killer liquor bans in SA, Distell posted a double-digit profit for 2nd half of 2020 says Group CEO Richard Rushton.
Read More
Woolworths' online food sales soar, but fashion business 'disappointing'
Woolworths is not paying an interim dividend, despite strong profit increase. The Money Show interviews Group CEO Roy Bagattini.
Read More
Discovery results: 'Strong operating performance, well-positioned for growth'
Earnings were negatively impacted by exchange rate volatility but Covid-19 provisions resilient, says Group CEO Adrian Gore.
Read More
Strong recovery for 2nd half of 2020 sees Anglo American weather a tough year
'I am immensely proud of how our team of more than 95,000 people across Anglo American pulled together' says CEO Mark Cutifani.
Read More
Sars plans to tax retirement funds if you leave SA, target offshore assets
The proposal to tax retirement fund members when no longer tax-resident in SA is not unreasonable, says Prof. Osman Mollagee.
Read More
Med scheme covers chemo treatment but not weekly Covid test required by hospital
Consumer ninja Wendy Knowler follows up on the case of a patient who'd been paying his membership dues for more than 40 years.
Read MoreMore from Local

Always wanted to own a piece of a wine farm? Here's how to make it a reality
Hemelzicht Vineyards, a new investment model that gives the public the opportunity to own a share in a luxury wine estate.
Read More
NEW GUIDELINES: Can parents now choose where to buy school uniform?
Competition Commission spokesperson Siyabulela Makinga says there's exploitation as schools sign exclusive deals with suppliers.
Read More
The WheelChair Doctor creates wheelchairs that can go up the stairs
Founder of The WheelChair Doctor Ernets Majenge explains why he started the business and his future goals.
Read More
Still no certainty on when water will be restored in some parts of Joburg
Joburg Water communications officer Eleanor Mavimbela gives an update on the water shutdown by Rand Water.
Read More
Study finds 40% of e-cigarettes shops located near universities and colleges
SAMRC scientist of the alcohol, tobacco and other drugs research unit Dr Catherine Egbe gives details of their research.
Read More
Public sector trade unions demand CPI plus 4% as final wage demand submitted
The demands have been submitted to the general secretary of the Public Service Coordinating Bargaining Council (PSCBC).
Read More
Sufficient prima facie evidence of misconduct against Mkhwebane, panel finds
The independent panel headed by retired Judge Bess Nkabinde recommended that a committee of the National Assembly investigates or launches an inquiry into Busisiwe Mkhwebane.
Read More
ConCourt to hear state capture contempt application against Zuma on 25 March
The former president failed to show up at the commission last month despite summonses and an order from the apex court to do so.
Read More
'SA will have COVID-19 resurgence if people behave like they did in 2020'
Pundits unpack their thoughts on the country moving from adjusted level 3 lockdown to level 1.
Read More
Unsuccessful applicants have a chance to appeal as soon as possible - NSFAS
National Students Financial Aid Scheme CEO Andile Nongogo gives an update on the application process for new students.
Read MoreMore from Lifestyle

Luxury living awaits you at Brookfield at Royal
Home is where the heart is... Invest in your family’s legacy and call the magnificent Brookfield at Royal home!
Read More
How to deal with cellphone addiction in a relationship
Clinical psychologist Khosi Jiyane explains the effects of cellphone addiction in relationships and how it can be resolved.
Read More
[WATCH] Moonstruck 2021 - CapeTalk's iconic music festival
CapeTalk's iconic summer music festival is back - and for the first time in its history, it's online.
Read More
Watch the finalist action from Week 4 of 2021 Dis-Chem Brain of 702
ICYMI - Gauteng's brightest minds delivered an epic final battle in the Dis-Chem Brain finale.
Read More
As export sales boost profit, Distell (Savanna, Klippies) eyes Africa expansion
Despite the killer liquor bans in SA, Distell posted a double-digit profit for 2nd half of 2020 says Group CEO Richard Rushton.
Read More
Tumi Morake: Acting has always been my first love
In this episode of Hanging out with Clement, media personality Tumi Morake speaks about her childhood, career and family.
Read More
Sars plans to tax retirement funds if you leave SA, target offshore assets
The proposal to tax retirement fund members when no longer tax-resident in SA is not unreasonable, says Prof. Osman Mollagee.
Read More
How much more alcohol will cost you after Mboweni's 2021 Budget Speech
Once again this year, you’ll be paying more for your sins.
Read More
Does an emotive Sars advert make you feel better about paying tax?
It's Budget day tomorrow and branding expert Sizakele Marutlulle chooses a topical campaign as her advertising hero of the week.
Read More
The Black Ties give us a taste of what to expect at Moonstruck
CapeTalk's iconic event Moonstruck in partnership with Simply Asia will take place virtually on Saturday, 27 February.
Read More