Lockdown regulations case was badly litigated - Pierre de Vos
Constitutional expert, Pierre De Vos says the North Gauteng High Court ruling that lockdown levels three and four are unconstitutional has merits of being appealed.
The court found that the lockdown regulations did not satisfy the rationality test and were not justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom as contemplated in Section 36 of the Constitution.
Speaking to Eusebius McKaiser, De Vos says regulations are judged on two standards which are rationality and the bill of rights.
Regulations must be compliant with the bill of rights. If any of the regulations limit a right then the test is more of a reasonable test because you have to ask if the limitation is reasonable and justifiable.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law professor - UCT
He explains why the judgment has merits for an appeal.
The problem for both sides, in this case, is that it was badly litigated from applicants and the respondents.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law professor - UCT
It will probably be appealed... the appeal will probably overturn the judgment.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law professor - UCT
Listen to the full interview below...
Spokesperson Thabo Masebe says the province needs assistance in making sure that people comply with COVID-19 regulations.Read More
Health Minister Zweli Mkhize announced on Sunday that the number of cases is now 196,750. There were 8,773 new infections.Read More
Stakeholder and communications head Kaizer Kganyago unpacks how his unit will handle this investigation.Read More
The ILEX Genehecker donated to the institution by Gift of the Givers will allow better turnaround time.Read More
Eyewitness News reporter Edwin Ntshidi says about 200 workers downed tools saying their lives are being put at risk of COVID-19.Read More
Flyer Magazine editor Guy Leitch talks about HEPA filters in airlines and social distancing when flying.Read More
The Herald reporter Ziphozethu Ncokazi gives details of Premier Oscar Mabuyane's media briefing.Read More
The health minister says people need to understand that everyone needs to work together in fighting the spread of the virus.Read More
MedScheme chief medical officer Dr Lungi Nyathi says they are hoping not to have high medical aid contributions for 2021.Read More
Masuku says they are concerned about shopping malls and the CBD as the number of COVID-19 infections increases.Read More