Succession issues leading to conflicts in several South African churches

Several churches in South Africa have in their constitution a succession plan of who takes over as leader of the church when the incumbent passes away or leaves the position. But these constitutions hardly indicate how this succession takes place.

This is according to Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva, Chairperson of the Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL).

The constitutions of churches must be very clear about these things (succession plans), in order to prevent a lot of fights within the church that are unnecessary

Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva, CRL Commission Chairperson

On Tuesday, the Durban High Court ruled that Vela Shembe is the rightful leader of the Nazareth Baptist Church, popularly known as the Shembe Church.

Since 2011, the Shembe Church has been fractured by two factions led by individuals who have claimed leadership of the church after the death of Vimbeni Shembe.

Vela Shembe leads the Thembelihle faction, while Mduduzi Shembe leads the much larger eBuhleni faction.

What we've discovered is that most constitutions are not very clear on succession plans, which has caused a lot of crisis in the country. Its just that the Shembe issue is a national issue. But you'd be surprised at how many thousands of churches, smaller ones, have a similar problem

Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva, CRL Commission Chairperson

Xaluva says that the CRL Commission has made its recommendations for churches to have clarity on succession in their constitutions.

She says that churches in the country need to clarify their constitutions if they are vague about succession plans.

Listen to the conversation below:

In iziHlabelelo it is written that a son must always take over (leadership of the Shembe church). This is what they've been doing all along

Sanele in Pretoria

You have a will that is in place, on the other hand you've got the constitution. The question is which framework between the two should supersede the other one

Lebohang in Rustenburg
Read More
'Haiti is the missing piece in the AU'

'Haiti is the missing piece in the AU'

Ambassador of Haiti to South Africa Jacques Baril describes Haiti's historic relationship with the African continent.

'Having sex will not make you cleverer'

'Having sex will not make you cleverer'

Neurologist Professor Girish Modi describes the effect of sex on one's memory.

Money Matters: Understanding an endowment policy

Money Matters: Understanding an endowment policy

Discovery's Head of Legal Services Harry Joffe describes on #NightTalk relevant information about endowment policies.

How to survive a hostile job interview

How to survive a hostile job interview

Recruitment specialist Candice Martin describes how one can get past a hostile job interview

'State must apologise and compensate Marikana families' - legal representative

'State must apologise and compensate Marikana families' - legal representative

SERI's Nomzamo Zondo describes the process the families of injured and killed Marikana miners have gone through to get compensation from the state.

Recognising the experience of women in South African mines

Recognising the experience of women in South African mines

Dr Asanda Benya has done work to put under the spotlight the role of women in the occupational culture of South African mines.

Popular articles
10 sexting tips on how to keep things spicy (and safe)

10 sexting tips on how to keep things spicy (and safe)

Interested in sexting but worried about the risks? Dr Eve has created a guideline to help you 'sext' in a fun and responsible way.

Vaal Dam about to reach 100% capacity

Vaal Dam about to reach 100% capacity

A few months ago the dam was only 27% full.

Confrontations between Somalis and locals, police fire rubber bullets

Confrontations between Somalis and locals, police fire rubber bullets

The #ForeignerMarch has turned violent. Police had to use stun grenades and rubber bullets to disperse the crowd.

Letters show Moyane refuses to account to Gordhan, turns to Zuma to intervene

Letters show Moyane refuses to account to Gordhan, turns to Zuma to intervene

M&G reports that Sars Commissioner Tom Moyane declared an intergovernmental dispute against Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan.

Violence breaks out in Atteridgeville amid #XenoMarch

Violence breaks out in Atteridgeville amid #XenoMarch

Tensions are high in Atteridgeville as a group calling itself Mamelodi Concerned Residents prepares to march against immigrants.

Where is that corrupt bastard? - EFF MP to Brian Molefe

Where is that corrupt bastard? - EFF MP to Brian Molefe

Former Eskom CEO Brian Molefe was sworn in as a Member of Parliament replacing Abram Mudau this week.

Mashaba says violent Jozi@work protests in Joburg Council orchestrated by ANC

Mashaba says violent Jozi@work protests in Joburg Council orchestrated by ANC

Joburg mayor Herman Mashaba has condemned the violence in the strongest possible terms and says he will lay charges.